If a market were as the simplistic theory describes, all the drivers would be completely independent, set their own terms, and all product manufacturers would negotiate with all the drivers and all the consumers would negotiate etc. It would be totally inefficient and impractical, but we'd have actual competition and supply/demand etc.
Reality is Amazon is a massive organization with a top-down power structure and massive power inequities. Consumers are individual people with no comparable organizational power. The idea that each individual consumer should make decisions that mediate the power of the massive corporation is a farce.
Nobody said consumers have to be individuals, consumers can organize just like low wage workers should. They have just been sold individualism thanks to centuries of propaganda. Rich people have no problem organizing, that's what corporations are, but somehow when people at the bottom of the ladder do, it is a bad thing? This is puritan morals, "rich are blessed with wealth, poor people only deserve contempt" and it certainly defines America.
I agree that massive organized consumer groups or institutions can make a difference.
You get a large bloc of people to act, they will notice.
http://freakonomics.com/podcast/do-boycotts-work-a-new-freak...
The fact is, if you want this service, you will create stress for drivers. Why is that bad?
That said, my post suggested that people would be better off if they purchased elsewhere because it is often cheaper to buy elsewhere than it is to buy off Amazon. That is an economic reality and one that naturally lends itself to people buying from Amazon's competitors. The suggestion of a boycott was the furthest thing from my mind.
A boycott is a powerful weapon in the context of a broader grassroots movement. We'll get there with Amazon soon -- they're too big to not step into a turd that generates sufficient discord.
Anyway, I listened to that podcast myself a while back. The conclusion was that boycotts rarely work, and when they do, it's mostly a bar PR issue rather than an economic per-sale issue.
I think right set of regulations is the answer. Companies should not be allowed to optimize people to such an extent.
I open browser, type amazon.com, search stuff, click 'buy with one-click'. I do not worry about delivery time, and I can just return without any hustle.
Compare with what you suggested, let's say we choose ebay (probably the 2nd-best online retailer): I open browser, search, found item, click through, buy the item, probably need to pay shipping, but the overall price is cheaper. I might get the item in time, or not. When I want to return, I might get a smooth transaction, or not. The customer service is guaranteed to be inferior to Amazon's.
In the process, I probably can save a few percentage on item price. But does it really make economic sense at all? If I buy one item on ebay, and for some reason I dont like it and could not return it; while with Amazon I am sure that I can always avoid this. Does the a few percentage saving actually save me? I don't believe that.
The plain trend of Amazon eating the retail market lends little credit to your claim "Buying things from Amazon no longer makes economic sense for most people".
No - the 'free market' is at work here. The workers absolutely do not have the power to set any terms at all.
The issue is that the 'free market' is ultimatley a game over power - and when one entity has a lot, and others are divided and weak - salaries would be basically zero for them: just enough to survive. It would be much below min. wage as an entire economy of 'sub-dollar store' communities would develop. Much like favelas in Brazil etc..
For most people, we have some market power because of our skills, but for manual labour, they have none, which is why worker protections and min. wage laws exist.
What I meant really is that the premise of "free market" the way the propagandists push it is a farce. As long as there are power imbalances, then the ideas about how free markets lead to all this efficiency etc. don't hold up, i.e. as long we we're talking about reality, free market dogma doesn't hold up.
I was speculating that the source of the "each consumer should make decisions, we as consumers can hold Amazon accountable" is rooted in some naive free-market type of dogma. I'm not sure the original poster indeed came from that (whether subconsciously or not)
Communism and Socialism is such a perniciously appealing idea: 'just let the government control everything and everything will be fair - take stuff from rich people and give it to the poor!'.
Young people have a really have a hard time with the paradox:
It's easy to understand an authoritative, centralized system that controls everything and 'maximizes efficiency'.
It's hard to understand how independent agents, working in a loosely collaborative 'free market' can actually provide much better efficiency in most scenarios.
Most nations had to go through some heavy duty socialism to realize that it doesn't work very well - and it will be ongoing: teachers and professors aren't a fan, and they push socialist ideals for the 20 years or so of your education, and it all seems cozy from inside an academic setting.
It's usually not until people have responsibility, i.e. children or management, or a small business (even consulting) do people start to clue in.
Yes - there are some hardcore people - like those at the Chicago school etc. who think that basically there should almost be 'no government' but they are not that common. Even Republicans usually expand government. Since the dawn of the USA... government has really never receded - it's only grown it's share of the economy - so the 'driving voice' that's needed is that of 'free markets with decent regulation', I think. And moral and benevolent leadership. Anyhow. I write too much :)
Now, if I was actually arguing or believed some anti-market dogma, it wouldn't be a straw-man here. But I fully agree that markets are valuable, are easy to over-regulate, and that there are many aspects of market freedom that are positive. I'm just not dogmatic about it. Dogma is what leads people to insist that things are a certain way because their dogmatic model says so rather than base their beliefs on evidence, etc.
But anyway, communist and socialist dogma may be wrong because they are dogmatic, but here's one thing I know for certain: your description of their dogma is completely wrong. Dogmatic communists and socialists don't believe what you just wrote in describing them.
Also, dogma is: "a principle or set of principles laid down by an authority as incontrovertibly true."
There is not that much 'free market' dogma (i.e. free markets are perfect, and always good) in mainstream American society.
There is a lot of socialist dogma in mainstream society. Communist dogma would indicate that capitalism is inherently wrong (as an absolute truth) and this is promoted quite a lot. Socialist dogma would indicate that mostly free markets are incompatible with the wellbeing of society.
Socialist dogma pervades European elitist thinking and popular sentiment, so much so, that any contradiction of their 'dogmatic beliefs' is considered 'far right wing'.
Watch 5 Hollywood films: the 'evil bad guy' while be an old white banker or business man 3 out of 5 times. American pop culture goes out of their way to vilify business (unless it's startups). There are obvious hints of dogma in this.
You are now continuing to make more straw men. None of the rest of your comment is actually addressing anything I was saying, just arguing with some image you have of people who you think believe certain things.
Note that I happen to think your perspective is really skewed here — the vast majority of power in our society is vested in capitalist interests, the media and government and lots more are very much capitalist or capitalist-apologist, and truly dogmatic free-market ideologies (it doesn't matter whether there's a great-man behind some dogma, just the idea that the authority is some idealistic free-market theory, that's authority enough to be called "dogma" — it's super rampant, enough that it's easy to run into believers constantly.
>Young people have a really have a hard time with the paradox
It explains why many people feel they're entitled to a job and government ought to 'create' jobs. It is incredibly perplexing just how many people don't understand that they aren't entitled to anything! The concept that you have to provide value for someone else so that you can get compensated eludes more people than it should. It is no wonder employers find themselves trying to explain such simple facts to fresh graduates that think they're entitled to jobs. Many of them (employees) don't understand that once they're on-boarded into a business, they immediately become liabilities until they can provide more value than they're receiving in form of compensation (heck, it isn't even compensation at this stage because compensation implies some form of quid pro quo).
>Yes - there are some hardcore people - like those at the Chicago school etc. who think that basically there should almost be 'no government'
Actually, the Chicago school isn't as 'hardcore' as you might think. We, the Austrians, are the ones who think that a society can exist without conventional government. It may come as a surprise to you but based on your statement - so the 'driving voice' that's needed is that of 'free markets with decent regulation' - you yourself fit the description of what many would consider the Chicago school which essentially maintains that a government that is small in size, mildly favors laissez-faire, has minimal regulations and pumps in money into the economy in smaller doses would suffice.
If you're interested in learning more about these and more thoughts, check out a book called: Democracy, The god That Failed by Hans-Hermann Hoppe
Prime (free) Video could be seen as simply a sales channel for their paid video.
https://www.google.com/amp/www.techtimes.com/amp/articles/17...
They ought to be subsidizing it with higher prices.
No, this is not quite reasonable.
Consumers do not realistically have this kind of power, especially vis-a-vis very large entities.
It would take a massive, massive informational campaign, massive awareness, coordination, coordination in the press etc..
For the same reason in the 19th century, before unions, people couldn't just 'not shop somewhere'.
Labour practices are best codified in law and policy.
I'm not a big fan of unions, where they are entrenched, they often have too much power ...
But where unions are 'possibly forming', it's usually for a very good reason.
Salaries for many working class jobs can't be left entirely up to the free market, otherwise they'd be earning next to zero.
It's really quite a paradox how benevolent Bezos and his ideological friends seem to be, all their charities blah blah blah and yet they treat many of their labour workers terribly. There are some real horror stories from the picking/packing plants.