Evolution Made Really Smart People Long to Be Loners
inverse.com
inverse.com
What does being in a savanna have anything to do with population densities and intelligence? The article doesn't really say. The only pertinent point seems to be about collective problem solving and intelligent people needing less help when it comes to solving problems. Which is kinda a tautology. The article then goes on to conclude that being in dense urban environments and being a loner are correlated with intelligence which seems like a non-sequitur.
But its not non-sequitor, and it doesn't really go on to conclude anything. If this is accurate, all it is saying is that intelligent people, who appear to enjoy being alone more, are well suited for life in a busy urban environment where you spend less time interacting wth fiends and family and therefore more intelligent people migrate to urban environments.
Again, if this is accurate, this isnt saying cities make people smarter (causation), its saying that smart people are drawn to less interactive environments which happens to be cities. it's the exact definition of correlation.
tl;dr: nothing ground breaking here, smart people like to be left alone and alone is now defined as living in urban environments.
The savanna is a big place. You survive in smallish groups of people or die. You have to have your wits about you to survive.
"The savanna theory of happiness is the idea that life satisfaction is not only determined by what’s happening in the present but also influenced by the ways our ancestors may have reacted to the event."
We have adapted in the past to conditions that we now do not live in. But you are right there is no definitive link between sparsely population in savanna and crowded cities made in the article. It could be claimed to be the savanna effect. It could be smarter people are slightly more introverted. Conjecture, not conclusive.
The thought that this is side effect of my problem solving skills and not needing a community to help with most things is interesting way of thinking about how I interact with society.
I assume others here may feel the same way?
"Country roads, take me home... to my friends: How intelligence, population density, and friendship affect modern happiness"
Published in British Journal of Psychology (2016)
Abstract: "We propose the savanna theory of happiness, which suggests that it is not only the current consequences of a given situation but also its ancestral consequences that affect individuals’ satisfaction and explains why such influences of ancestral consequences might interact with intelligence. We choose two varied factors that characterize basic differences between ancestral and modern life – population density and frequency of socialization with friends – as empirical test cases. As predicted by the theory, population density is negatively, and frequency of socialization with friends is positively, associated with life satisfaction. More importantly, the main associations of life satisfaction with population density and socialization with friends significantly interact with intelligence, and, in the latter case, the main association is reversed among the extremely intelligent. More intelligent individuals experience lower life satisfaction with more frequent socialization with friends. This study highlights the utility of incorporating evolutionary perspectives in the study of subjective well-being."
I skimmed the paper. The theory sounds plausible, but much more research seems needed.
An issue: Apparently the "intelligent" group has an IQ cutoff point at 115 (1 SD above mean), that doesn't sound like 'the extremely intelligent' used in the abstract.