Basically, markdown has (at least) two use-cases:
1. A safe (if you do HTML sanitization properly) way to let people mark-up their input on web comment sites like HN, StackOverflow, etc. This is probably the most common use-case.
2. A web authoring tool. This was the intended use-case.
Supporting arbitrary HTML is absolutely inadmissible for (1); not having arbitrary HTML is basically inexcusable for (2). And yeah, I could write the posts in straight HTML, but honestly that's a pain. Why shouldn't there be a tool that makes writing styled-text-with-lists-and-headings easy but lets me drop down to HTML when I need to?