1) consistency with observed phenomena, especially
consistent, multi-dimensional correlations
2) predictive strength, including accurate and
precise predictions (direct or indirect) coming to pass
that demonstrate the explanatory power of a theory
3) lack of alternative, more persuasive theories
None are necessary and none are always sufficient to cause us to tentatively adopt a theory of causation. But the stronger the evidence the better. Note that all three are, strictly speaking, categories of correlation; all are circumstantial. Therefore all science is fundamentally based on correlation. There's always the possibility of some kind of hidden structure or alternative explanation; you cannot rule out all such possibilities, only a subset. You select a working theory, if at all, from among the remaining, proposed explanations by heuristic and probabilistic methodologies.If you reject climate change because it doesn't prove causation, then you're literally rejecting all of science. There is no scientific theory nor any kind of empirical "fact" that you cannot cast doubt upon in such a manner.
I won't even touch your other points.