Never again! We even had to stop using them as long term storage disks just in case... (though it appears heat was the main issue for them)
Back when I used desktop drives, I had several outages caused by a bad disk in a mirror. I log into the box and manually fail it out of the raid and we are good, but customers tend to get mad when their I/O hangs for hours on end.
It only takes one hung mirror in production, for me at least, to pay for a whole lot of 'enterprise' firmware drives.
http://www.t13.org/Documents/UploadedDocuments/docs2007/D169...
Until recently, you often needed a vendor-supplied MS-DOS executable to enable or modify ERC features on consumer drives, but smartmontools supports it as of v5.40, thanks to this guy:
http://www.csc.liv.ac.uk/~greg/projects/erc/
I just bought a 1.5TB Samsung HD154UI for $99 that supports ERC. There are reports that P-model variants of the WD 15EADS don't support TLER anymore, but I have several S- and R-model variants of that drive that do, including one that was manufactured in March; so it's still possible to get WD consumer drives that support TLER/ERC, you just have to be picky about the variant.