You can't protect all people from themselves, but you can protect a lot of people from themselves.
If you look at smoking [1] in the US, smoking went from 42.4% in 1965 to 16.8% in 2014. Raising awareness, taxing cigarettes, outlawing advertising, warnings on packaging, these things work.
The same could be done with alcohol if society wanted. One of the reasons why it hasn't happened with alcohol is because alcohol is ingrained into our culture.
> by the percentage of people saved by life saving drugs that make it to market faster/would otherwise be blocked.
Do you have any estimates for this? Do you have estimates about how many people would die by allowing poorly-vetted drugs on the market?
> which of course goes down significantly when people realize that they shouldn't blindly trust everything in our markets
How would you suggest the average person go about evaluating a drug/treatment?
> sentenced to die directly by rejecting appeals from terminally ill patients to get access to experimental drugs/procedures
sentenced to die implies that experimental drugs/procedures would save them. Undoubtedly some could be saved, but I doubt it would be more than a small fraction.
[1] https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/tables/trends/ci...
Government bureaucrats are not special or different from us regular folk. Why should we expect them to be?
The issue is education. It's very difficult to tell what is healthy and what isn't. There is a lot of research coming out that shows us sugar and starches are very bad for us. The stress from those carbs can damage our arteries and is what allows cholesterol to build.
The industry has a vested interest in people not knowing/believing in that. Sugar and HF Corn Syrup is a massive industry. Soda companies have been losing money as people finally move away and now we start to see the tides change.
Regardless, we need good education about what is and isn't health. Otherwise people struggle with weight and just get frustrated and resolve themselves to eat unhealthy because nothing seems to help reduce their weight or cravings.
Most software does not involve life-and-death situations. In cases that do, e.g. the space shuttle, they don't use rapid iteration [1].