We don't want legality. The reason why the situation is really bad currently is because back in 2008, CITES lifted restrictions on ivory sales which allowed several African nations to sell their ivory stockpiles to China and Japan. The current situation is believed to be a direct result of this and the demand has skyrocket since then.
In 80's, there was a similar poaching crisis, what eventually put an end to it was making as much of the trade as possible illegal.
War on drugs and poaching are similar only on the superficial level. Read my comment below where I talk about it.