Equity crowdfunding eliminates both of those guardrails. So it's reasonable to ask how effective they'll be (at generating returns for retail investors) given the obvious issue of fraud (and incompetence).
Remember the 'startup story' we read here? [1] This CEO convinced his employees to cover payroll, you don't think he couldn't convince your mom?
I hope you (or someone you care about) never experiences a really good con artist first hand because it completely shakes your belief in humanity to the core. These people will take everything you have if you let them, and they will do it without hesitation. This is how it goes;
Your family member or friend calls you to tell you that they just got in on a really good deal. They are going to be rich and you can be too. They will tell you how this company their new friend is the owner/CEO/president of has discovered some new product/bitcoin/algorithm/process/material that is going to disrupt some multi-billion or multi-trillion dollar a year industry. They will have some really great story about either how the information was suppressed or some "unknown genius" that they befriended/are/know came at it from a completely new direction and the world was going to change overnight. They just need some money to get their first prototype demonstrable and bam the value of your investment will grow by 100x easy.
Now you ask them about it and find a lot of things that you find suspicious so you ask them to ask questions. If the questions are too pointed the prankster will threaten them with not taking their money (and so losing out on this huge reward) and if they have bought the story they will shut up. The trick here is they think they are already rich because they are convinced it is such a sure thing. And no amount of reasoning from you will change their mind.
When it finally is revealed that the money is gone and the "company" is shutting down, there will be a set of things that happened that appeared to be either extremely unlikely or extremely rare. In one story the "technical cofounder" who had all the secret sauce in their head was killed in a freak car accident in Russia while visiting their family to bring them back to the US.
The crowd funding site will be set up with layer after layer of warnings that you can lose all your money, and there won't be a single shred of printed information that could prove that the people responsible didn't believe what they were saying when they convinced your loved ones to invest.
Bottom line, you won't be able to prove fraud, people you care about may have had their entire life's savings taken and are now living in poverty on government benefits, and there will be nothing you can do about it.
The only things that stands between these fraudsters and your grandmother are the Qualified Investor rules.
[1] https://medium.com/startup-grind/i-got-scammed-by-a-silicon-...
This happens to VCs too. So? This is why investing into companies is risky.
Then that's your fault for thinking something is a 100% sure thing. Are you expecting the government to protect people from their own bad decisions?
Never invest more than you're willing to lose. Never.
And it's not a small problem, there are a lot of "fools" out there. That's why these laws got made in the first place.
There's a shocking level of fraud successfully targeted at "sophisticated" investors every year. Most of it just doesn't get much coverage.
Depends on what you mean by "Do I have the right to clean out your parents bank account and get them to get a second mortgage on their house..."
If they decide to invest in something and have to do those things to get cash and it goes bad, oops on them.
If you commit fraud and get access to their financials and clean them out, oops on you.
We give a lot of leeway for people to solicit support of new inventions and ideas. There also happens to be a lot of pyramid schemes and similar get rich quick scams.
I don't have a fool proof way for seeing a scam from a score. If a kickstarter has specific data, date targets, shows they've done some work and made connections, I am more inclined to have a go.
If someone is saying "Get your friends to sell tupperware, you'll be rich in no time!" with little detail otherwise, I'll laugh and say no thanks.
a) Sell (or pre-sell) inventions --- but those sales logically offer only the capped upside of the product itself, and nobody will leverage themselves to get access to that upside.
b) Join as a part-time employee an affiliate sales program for an invention --- this sometimes does involve leverage (and when it does, that's when you see companies settling like Herbalife did), but there's also a time commitment that mitigates the risk.
c) Solicit investment from accredited investors who, by dint of substantial resources, are presumed to be sophisticated enough either to evaluate the investment or to not be subjecting themselves to existential financial risk by participating.
d) Solicit investment from the public after completing onerous compliance and disclosure programs.
What's being discussed today is something in between (c) and (d), where investments can be marketed directly to the public, to people we cannot presume to be sophisticated or financially secure, with virtually none of the disclosure and compliance requirements of a public company. It's reasonable to be skeptical of this.