The reality is that speech recognition, language translation, face recognition, object classification and detection, semantic segmentation, speech and image synthesis have improved by extraordinary leaps and bounds in recent years. If we used the logic that past failures inform a confident belief that future success in a challenge will inevitably fail, then we should've bet heavily against Alpha Go defeating one of the most accomplished human Go champions in the world. Self driving cars seem like a sci-fi fantasy until they become a mundane reality.
There's an irrational arrogance to human beings in general, and Wall Street types in particular, regarding the specialness / non-reproducibility of their intelligence. It's not unlike the belief that people had that organic molecules were somehow special, "vital," and not synthesizable from base elements.
Certainly, there's a long way to go to replicate the capabilities of a human brain, but I don't think we should exaggerate or fetishisize the human power to estimate and mitigate risk. We've seen many spectacular failures of that in recent years.