To me that sounds like the end-state is a Chimera and not a Lion, without any incremental end-user benefits along the way.
To me that sounds like the end-state is a Chimera and not a Lion, without any incremental end-user benefits along the way.
This is an aesthetic judgment. There is no such things as «a Lion» in the real world. Engineering is the work of building chimeras that solve your problems.
> without any incremental end-user benefits along the way.
The expected benefits are :
- speed (thanks to the massive parallelization permitted by Rust «fearless concurrency»)
- reliability (thanks to Rust's memory safety to avoid crashes and better type system that helps reducing the number of bugs)
- security (thanks to Rust's memory safety to avoid exploits)
Component from Servo will be included in Gecko one by one, the user will gain on these three fronts each time a new component is included.
Creating a new langauges to incrementally change and clean-slate rewrite is an orders-of-magnitude bigger investment than what either what Joel's criticizing or advocating. I don't think that article is very relevant here one way or the other.
There can be legacy system that can just be maintained without modifying. Like for example JavaScript engine.