> This really doesn't make any sense.
Disagree. Below, I respond to each of your points.
> Blockchains aren't immutable, they are just expensive to mutate.
Agreed; very little is truly absolutely immutable. It's all shades of grey. I actually prefer the word "tamper-resistant" and I usually say that next to the "immutable" definition, such as in the first paragraph of https://bigchaindb.com/whitepaper. But "immutable" makes for a good shorthand, especially because that's the label that the community uses.
> Blockchains aren't centralized.
Oops, that was a typo. I meant to say "decentralized". Fixed it. (That was a pretty big oops!)
> Blockchains didn't introduce audit trails ...
Correct.
> ... [status quo] require[s] trust in the central authority
Exactly. And it's crucial to note that once you don't have to trust a central authority to store your audit trail, you have a way more trustworthy audit trail that improves many applications and unlocks new ones.
> The author has a poor understanding of both AI and blockchain technology ... "treatise on altcoins"
Disagree. First, you don't need an "altcoin" to have a blockchain. To understand of what's special about blockchains, you first have to understand what already exists for distributed databases, then what the delta is.
Second, consensus in a distributed database has been around for decades; Satoshi did not invent it. Lamport laid down much of the theory for FT and BFT consensus in 1982. What Bitcoin brought forward, in addition to BFT-ish consensus, was Sybil tolerance (addressing attack-of-the-clones).
Third, as for my understanding of AI: I've been doing it professionally since the late 90s; here are my publications: http://trent.st/publications. Doing AI in the 90s was one of the least popular things one could possibly do, so I certainly didn't do it for the hype.
> vaguely proposing using a blockchain as a mass datastore (with ownership labels)
Obviously I gave much more specific proposals than that. I have other writings that dive into more detail on some of the use cases, such as an IP registry [1] and for AI DAOs [2].
[1] https://medium.com/ipdb-blog/a-decentralized-content-registr... [2] https://medium.com/@trentmc0/ai-daos-and-three-paths-to-get-...