> Customers don't care about tracking, as you say, but not because they've thought about the issue and concluded the trade-off is in their benefit -- in reality they've never thought about the issue at all. Regular people are indifferent to iPhone privacy until they're asked if they ever have conversions or ever take photos they don't want to become public. And then it all clicks, and then they do care about their privacy.
Yes I suppose if you draw an unrealistic line between data collection and Facebook suddenly sharing photos you could scare up any sort of response you want.
Sharing content vs app usage metadata are quite different in point of fact though.
> People don't care, until they do.
Yes. I suppose this is true in the sense that it's tautological. I only bring that up because of your meticulous dedication to discarding social context in:
> When you call telemetry "benign" you're begging the question: the definition of benign implies you can't reasonably be opposed to it. So that's fallacious.
(P.S., this is not "begging the question". "Begging the question" is not "Obviously we should ask." If you're going to use a technical term, perhaps look up its technical definition? I do not think this assertion is unusually cyclical.)
> I see this as an effort to appease disgruntled customers, not as PR stunt.
I sure do wish people would hold desktop to the same uncompromising standard they hold Windows to...
> And as somebody else pointed out already, it still isn't possible to opt-out entirely.
Actually, they were referring to the current state of affairs for specific editions of windows. We are not entirely sure how this will change with the new edition.