They dropped the DUI charges but are still going after him for reckless driving.
http://www.sfgate.com/crime/article/Prosecutor-drops-DUI-cha...
They dropped the DUI charges but are still going after him for reckless driving.
http://www.sfgate.com/crime/article/Prosecutor-drops-DUI-cha...
“Without a confirmatory test of the specific drug in the
defendant’s system that impaired his ability to drive, we
do not believe we can prove the charge beyond a reasonable
doubt,” said Krishna Abrams, the district attorney.
I'm bothered by the "armchair conviction" here by the DA. I get this is probably standard lawyer boilerplate, but she's insinuating his guilt in the court of public opinion. Is there a libel/slander case here? (Probably not.)Second, I'm confused whether he was charged with reckless driving at the time of arrest, or if this is a later charge. Also confused about the "charges were not brought until... nearly 10 months after incident" line in the original article.
I'm assuming the story goes like this:
Man was pulled over for driving erratically (e.g., weaving through traffic). He is given a field sobriety test and fails. He is charged with DUI and reckless driving. The initial blood test reveals no known (i.e., testable) substances of which he could have been under the influence. The sample is sent for a second, more intensive round of testing. It reveals no new information other than caffeine. The DUI charge is not immediately dropped, and the defendant uses the opportunity to push the "charged for DUI for caffeine" story. The DUI charge is finally dropped. The reckless driving charge continues, and will go to court this year.
My opinion is that the DA really wanted to prosecute the DUI charge ("he had to be under the influence of something!"), so they took their sweet time trying to find an angle.
This one screams to me that his main offense was pissing off someone with authority in an unmarked car who went on to do everything possible to make his life miserable.
If I had to bet I'd suspect he got into some mild road rage incident with this state employee, flipped her off or something, and this is the payback.
Just a theory, read the story again and read between the lines of the initial reported incident.
"he was pulled over by an agent from the California department of alcoholic beverage control, who was driving an unmarked vehicle. The agent said Schwab had cut her off and was driving erratically"
Pulled over by an alcohol beverage control agent whom he had cut off. Oy.
ABC are hiring.
here's the job spec.
<---begin quote--->
THE POSITION
The Agent, Alcoholic Beverage Control, is a deep class with three alternate ranges. Responsibilities include, but are not limited to, conducting independent investigations of criminal and/or administrative violations committed on or about alcoholic beverage control licensed premises by licensees, their employees, and/or members of the general public; and interpreting and explaining the provisions of the laws, rules, and regulations of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Act, Penal Code, Health and Safety Code, and Vehicle Code.
Agents at Range A are entry level and conduct independent investigations of criminal and/or administrative violations committed on or about alcoholic beverage control licensed premises by licensees, their employees, and/or members of the general public; locate and interview witnesses and persons suspected of violations; collect and preserve evidence to support administrative action and/or prosecution; determine type of case and develop investigation plan; prepare clear, concise, and accurate documents and reports detailing investigation activities and findings; maintain accurate master investigation case files; develop field operation plans, and safely executing them; perform undercover assignments and surveillance operations; provide technical assistance to law enforcement agencies and others; make physical arrests; maintain liaison with Federal, State, and local law enforcement agencies; and testify in criminal court and/or administrative hearings.
Agents at Range B are journey level and conduct more complex and difficult investigations and demonstrate a broader knowledge and application of investigative techniques and procedures. Agents, in addition to the above, conduct undercover and high-profile criminal investigations; and write, secure, and serve arrest and search warrants.
Agents at Range C are full journey level and conduct or participate in the most difficult and sensitive investigations. In addition to all of the above, investigations include, but are not limited to, vice, gambling, prostitution
<---end quote--->
Presumably they are sworn law enforcement officers, and as such have the technical ability to enforce the law generally, but it's really clear that the person in question has a job enforcing liquor license law, and was outside their normal job description on this one.
It's equivalent to a fish and game warden grabbing a shoplifter while at the mall. It's allowed and legal, but not normal.
It's abnormal from the beginning, by the end it's pretty clearly abusive.
I think we should start investigating the rest of this DA's cases. To see if everyone she dealt with was railroaded. And if evidence was disregarded in their cases too.
I don't understand this reading between the lines.
You're disregarding a lot of facts here. If you're in a road rage incident with somebody as a state employee, you'll be wanting to reduce paperwork instead of increase it. You don't want a paper record at all, or if you have a paper record, you'll want it for something like resisting arrest or something vague like that.
Second, an equally valid reading is that this guy was driving erratically, the officer pulled him over because she thought that he was enough of a danger to the public that he should be stopped, and he was acting as though he was too impaired to drive.
Then the DA, based on the officer's testimony, wanted to get the driver for DUI as that's a more serious crime, but settled on reckless driving based on lack of evidence.
That fits the facts far better.
http://www.nbc29.com/story/23909588/virginia-abc-agents-viol...
Then the court seals the records to hide this, and the main policy change is that a uniformed cop must be present during this (these were undercover cops who'd pulled the guns) instead of - you know - not arresting someone at gunpoint for the pointless crime of buying bootleg liquor even if it was actually liquor.
It's also their essential function to prosecute people they believe they can prove guilty. It would be bizarre for a DA to be talking about prosecuting someone they didn't believe to be guilty.
(It's important to consider this possibility because then the fix has to be to the system, not just to try to find different people)
She is doing no such thing. She's just saying that without a positive drug test, she has no ground to prosecute. That's an awfully big step.
> My opinion is that the DA really wanted to prosecute the DUI charge ("he had to be under the influence of something!")
Agreed. Although they did take two blood tests, and sent them out for screening. The penalties for DUI are exponentially worse than the penalties for reckless driving, and it looks better for the DA and all prosecution parties involved if they can get a DUI instead of a lesser charge.
The DA should be saying "There's no evidence of that", not "There isn't enough to prosecute". She's lying by implying that there's a body of evidence that is just not quite sufficient to convict, as opposed to the FACT that all evidence points to not-guilty. Not insufficient, but directly contradicting the charges.
They're also prosecuting him for reckless driving. Reckless driving witnessed by an officer is also (some) evidence of driving while impaired.
> FACT that all evidence points to not-guilty. Not insufficient, but directly contradicting the charges.
You can be impaired while on legal substances that don't show up on drug tests. The officer's testimony makes the DA's statement perfectly valid. And the evidence aside from the chemical test tends to bolster the state's case.
Right, but they aren't just a lack of evidence for coked-up-driving, they're actually evidence FOR clean driving.
> They're also prosecuting him for reckless driving.
Well, they're using the reckless driving charge as a license to fish, falling back to it only when they've exhausted other avenues.
> "Without a confirmatory test of the specific drug in the defendant’s system that impaired his ability to drive, we do not believe we can prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt,”
The DA is taking for granted that he was on something and is blaming the tests for failing to show that, not using that as evidence that she might be mistaken.
They go on to say "not believe we can prove the charge beyond" when they should be saying "believe there is no evidence whatsoever for this charge."
The tone of the article is that this man is guilty and the system is simply unable to prove it.
You stated that there was no evidence for impaired driving. Based on reported observed behavior it was.
> Well, they're using the reckless driving charge as a license to fish, falling back to it only when they've exhausted other avenues.
That's a huge assumption to make. What are they "fishing" for? They already have an officer making a statement that he was driving erratically. That's pretty much him dead to rights.
> they should be saying "believe there is no evidence whatsoever for this charge."
There is no chemical test evidence. There is plenty of behavioural evidence, evidence that warrants a reckless driving test.
> system is simply unable to prove it.
The system is very able to "prove" that he was driving poorly and he will be punished accordingly.
The only 'evidence' is the uncorroborated word of an officer. Yes, that counts, but no it's not evidence in any way. And more and more we're having officer testimony proved to be a lie on the evening news.
> That's a huge assumption to make. What are they "fishing" for?
Charges that will stick. The same as when they say they see erratic driving and demand to search your car. Something that will justify the cop-rage that resulted in the guy being pulled over.
> There is no chemical test evidence.
Oh no, in fact there's plenty of test evidence that he wasn't intoxicated. And all else being equal, a citizen who had a clean test is less likely to have been driving erratically than one who hasn't.
It's a logic error to assign weight to the accusation in absence of any positive evidence, and then use that weight to suggest that the negative evidence now doesn't apply.
> The system is very able to "prove" that he was driving poorly and he will be punished accordingly.
The system is able to punish him despite the lack of evidence. The word prove doesn't apply in any way. And in fact in proper terminology the system merely "finds" him guilty, it doesn't claim to prove guilt.
So it counts as evidence, but it's not really evidence? The word of an officer holds weight in court. Heck, the word of any eyewitness is evidence.
> Something that will justify the cop-rage
Instead of projecting feelings on the officer, how about the driver was driving so erratically that the officer felt as though the lives of bystanders were in danger?
> Oh no, in fact there's plenty of test evidence that he wasn't intoxicated.
No. There is no test you can take to prove that you weren't intoxicated. He was not intoxicated on any of the substances he was tested on.
> It's a logic error to assign weight to the accusation in absence of any positive evidence
The evidence in this case the the observation of the witness, an officer, which is evidence whether you see it that way or not. We're not talking about chemical tests here.
> The system is able to punish him despite the lack of evidence.
It seems like you're saying the word of an officer is somehow less than the word of a non-officer. If anybody gives eyewitness testimony to erratic driving, that's evidence. I don't see why you're talking around that.
No amount of eye-witnesses to recklessness amount to proof of intoxication. Let alone one uncorroborated, counter-factual, claim.
> Instead of projecting feelings on the officer,
If there was credible evidence of recklessness they'd have charged him with it. The fishing expedition is because the pretext is barely credible. It's possible that the officer alone witnessed this behavior, and there also isn't any corroborating evidence, but it's more likely just a false allegation.
How handy that an off-duty officer, whose camera wasn't running, noticed him instead of the myriad of on-duty officers on the same road.
> how about the driver was driving so erratically that the officer felt as though the lives of bystanders were in danger?
Right, and in other news the officer felt their life was in danger so they shot the person. We've seen how these are lies so I don't know why you would give the police witness any more credibility than anyone else's, which is to say essentially zero. But yes, it's not physically impossible just improbable.
> No. There is no test you can take to prove that you weren't intoxicated. He was not intoxicated on any of the substances he was tested on.
Right, but wrong. He was selected without knowledge of his state of intoxication, but because of suspicion, and with no prior association with the officer or other reason for being picked. If he's clean of all tested substances (which are of course the primary intoxicants which is why we test for them) he's likelier than a control person to actually be clean for all tested substances.
We've established that he's not in the group of drinkers, tokers, snorters, etc. He may be in the group of obscure tweakers on drug X that we can't detect, but he's much more likely just clean.
> The evidence in this case the the observation of the witness, an officer, which is evidence whether you see it that way or not. We're not talking about chemical tests here.
Right. But we gave the chemical tests weight, had they been positive he'd have been convicted on that evidence, because of the officer's testimony. He must have been on something... And now we dismiss the tests similarly because they contradict the officer's testimony. He must have been on something the tests don't catch... The test is being given undue weight based on its ability to prove or contest the officer's story.
For rigor, the test and the weight placed on it must be part of the proposition, not the conclusion. If the tests could provide evidence to convict for intoxication they must also provide substantial evidence of non-intoxication. (In randomly selected individuals. We could stack the deck by supplying just Drug X users, but he wasn't selected from a population likely to be high in Drug X usage.)
> It seems like you're saying the word of an officer is somehow less than the word of a non-officer.
Yes, absolutely. As long as an officer's word is given extra weight in court, I as a citizen and a logician must discount it and all evidence based on it proportionally.
> If anybody gives eyewitness testimony to erratic driving, that's evidence.
Some evidentiary weight, yes. Enough to get someone breathalyzed, maybe, but not enough for the charges to stick despite that. This example has the eyewitness testimony being proof enough for the DA who laments the failure of the tests, instead of recognizing the proper findings from them.
> I don't see why you're talking around that.
I'm not trying to talk around it, I'm addressing it directly.
Police testimony has an incredibly low bar and we've seen 1) a tremendous number of lies that contradict recorded fact, and 2) an almost total cover-up and complete defense of lying officers. It's an ad-hominem to say that someone is a liar and therefore dismiss their conclusion, but it's perfectly reasonable to say they're a known liar so it's likely they're lying, and discount appropriately.
She is doing no such thing. She's just saying that
without a positive drug test, she has no ground to
prosecute. That's an awfully big step.
It's a really nebulous statement: "Without a confirmatory test of the specific drug in the defendant’s system that impaired his ability to drive..." This can be interpreted two different, but equally semantically valid ways. The pessimist in me thinks this "double-speak" is intentional.Your interpretation is: "We don't have a test that shows the presence of any drug that impairs the defendant's ability to drive."
My alternate (but semantically valid) read was: "There was a drug in the defendant's system, we just don't know which one because nothing we tried tested positive."
Combine that with the valid but underhanded: "... prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt". Again: "We don't have a case" vs. "this guy is guilty but we just can't prove it legally".
The direct, unequivocal re-write would be: "We do not have a confirmatory test of any drug in the defendant's system that would impair his ability to drive. As such, we do not believe there is a valid case on this charge."