Nevertheless, I think the point I made in my previous comment is true.
Failure to rate them properly (giving them AAA ratings) led governments, banks, pension funds, insurance companies and other "safe" investors to invest vast sums, making that money available for subprime lending, leading to poor (nearly nonexistent) lending standards and the housing bubble, and when the bubble burst, forcing the government to eat private losses to prevent financial ruin.
But by bundling many such NINJA loans into complicated investments that few understood, mortgage writers were able to fund these loans with money from most risk averse investors.
Would anyone have been fooled by individual NINJA loans with AAA ratings?
Would anyone have been fooled by individual NINJA loans with AAA ratings?
This question betrays a gross misunderstanding of how mortgage securitization works. It's perfectly legitimate to construct AAA mortgages from arbitrarily bad loans, provided you've accurately quantified how bad they are.
I said not many - meaning, in particular, not the risk averse investors who control vast sums of other people's money and demand top rated securities.
Countrywide was making a profit off the resale of the loans, removing short term profits from the corporation, leading to personal gains even after the scheme failed, and Countrywide's CEO agreed to pay a "$22.5 million penalty to settle SEC charges that he and two other former Countrywide executives misled investors". Countrywide wasn't your typical investor.
> This question betrays a gross misunderstanding of how mortgage securitization works.
Your comment betrays a misunderstanding of what happened. People were fooled by the complexity.
I said nothing about the ability to construct accurately rated loans. The fact is that the MBSs and CDOs did fool many people, including the rating agencies.
And you didn't answer the question. How many would be fooled by a simple, individual, AAA rated NINJA loan?
And you didn't answer the question. How many would be fooled by a simple, individual, AAA rated NINJA loan?
The question is meaningless. Individual loans aren't rated (at least not on the same C-AAA scale that bond-like instruments are). Portfolios of loans are, as are securitized loans.
People were "fooled" by portfolios of loans in the exact same way they were fooled by securitized loans - they chose optimistic parameters for the nightmare scenarios. That's not complexity, that's just guessing wrong about one or two simple numbers.
And when the SEC sued, the CEO agreed to repay investors "$45 million in disgorgement of ill-gotten gains", but reportedly, because of an indemnification agreement, Countrywide the corporation (actually the corporation's new owner BofA) was forced to pay $20 million of that as well.
Hard to see that as anything but a scheme to "mislead investors".