Can behavioral science help in Flint?
newyorker.com
newyorker.com
Also yes I agree, safe potable water in the worlds richest country should not be an issue in 2017.
I also think that natural monopolies should be heavily state governed if not state owned.
Other countries do infrastructure better and have water that is demonstrably better than in a lot of places in the US.
It makes it hard to do a direct comparison since other countries don't have to do as much.
Perhaps the issue here isn't accountability but ability to do the change properly.
Crony capitalism is like a flesh eating disease. It encourages everyone to look solely after their own individual interests. Then once a portion of society is exploited and impoverished by the greedier part of society to the point of becoming a burden on them, the rich want to "cut them off" or let them rot away. The cycle then repeats, until very few are left at the top extremely wealthy and powerful, but with no middle class left to exploit.
Not sure what the solution is or that there is any single solution, wealth inequality seems to beget greater wealth inequality.
"A young man said, “I think the concern is that because we’re a Hispanic community we’re not going to have the same help.” His parents had brought him to Michigan from Mexico, at the age of ten. More than a decade later, in 2012, he’d become a beneficiary of Obama’s program for undocumented immigrants who had come to the country as children; it protected him from deportation, if only temporarily. Now, he said, besides the hazardous water, he feared immigration raids. “They already have all my information,” he explained. “I don’t have any criminal record. . . . I don’t have any tickets, no drinking and driving.” But he was concerned about his children, who, after they saw Trump on TV talking about mass deportations, asked him, “What’s going to happen to us?”
Really, it protected him from deportation? How wonderful. I guess it didn't protect the other 2.5 million people who were deported which, by the way, is the largest number of deportations under any president. The other part of that paragraph is probably correct - things definitely aren't going to get any better under Trump, but you can blame that on the Democrats and their dishonest approach with governing. They'd rather invest in white-washing their legacy than make an honest attempt at fulfilling their "progressive" platform promises. And I suspect this is the reason behind much of this article as well.
They are only paid to care about it or even be aware of it if it suits the needs of their designated group of oligarchs.
Coulter citation:
Here are some number showing ONLY interior removals: https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/wp-content/uplo...
But yes border removals also jumped as well.. Maybe there is already a wall there? Here is a breakdown of deportations by three categories (border, interior and unknown) https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/wp-content/uplo...
Certainly much of this is due to better tracking (dimishing of the unknown category), tighter enforcement, and more efficiency, but none of those arguments dispute the trend of higher deportations under Obama simply because it doesn't fit the overall narrative of Obama as a "compassionate" president.
http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-obama-deportations-20140...
You can accuse me of "reading too much into it" or "being overly selective in order to reinforce my worldview", but I'm not the one who decided to publish an article titled "CAN BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE HELP IN FLINT?"
You're making this a class-war thing, but it's not like politicians care about any other kind of citizens either. They sure as shit don't give a fuck about ordinary middle-income or ordinary high-income citizens either, not unless they've arranged themselves into politically powerful groups.
The owners invest in any means that will reassert the legitimacy of their dominance. That includes purchasing political influence sometimes by paying directly into the political apparatus and other times by manipulating the workers into giving consent to the policies they prefer.
TL;DR This is all personal opinion: My main issue is with the journalism here. To me this article was disrespectful to readers, scientists and the people of Flint. Without making any accusations, I would be curious to know how this article was researched and in what capacity the journalist and the scientist this article is about knew each other before the article was written? Were they friends or classmates? (I don't have a problem if a journalist wants to write about one of their friends per se, especially if that person is part of an interesting story worth telling, but from an ethics and respect for readers standpoint I think that should be disclosed).
I like The New Yorker and read it regularly but after reading this long, long piece something felt very off. There was a noticeable lack of substance and accuracy, along with flowery misleading writing when it came to the science/behavioral science stuff suggesting the article was under-researched. But then the tenor of the writing about the scientist was a completely incongruity to the rest of the article (the language often felt like a letter of recommendation to a grad school on behalf of a friend).
Honestly, I have no idea if there was conflict of interest and I don't really care. The writing just made it feel like something fishy is going on. I think most importantly, behavioral science is interesting and has potential to do good work in many areas and all. But the people of Flint have fucking lead in their water...So a fluff piece connecting behavioral science to the Flint water issue is misleading at best and potentially harmful. It's misleading about what behavioral science can and can't accomplish; Flint was a government fuck-up in a place with serious systemic issues that need to be addressed. Plus 99% of what the article connects to behavioral science is really just people paying attention and helping other people in person. No behavioral science magic involved. Also the fucking "write a song" part of the article was a joke, that's an idea any Joanne Shmoe can come up with, that part of the story was not real behavioral science and pretty disrespectful to everyone.
Also New Yorker: I get your readers might not be interested in detailed science articles and they might prefer people stories. But I am very confident they want accurate stories whatever the topic. If you waste their time overly long articles of bullshit you will lose more readers. Come on.