People starve to death because we find protecting property rights more important than letting them eat. How does it not make sense?
I am not saying that reducing enforcement of property rights does not negatively affect the owner. I am saying that there are plenty of cases where property rights reduces the ability of others to make us of it.
This makes it a tradeoff, not something worthy of absolutes.
> That's like saying preventing people from feasting on your flesh makes them all poorer.
And of course it would - if they enjoy human flesh and were denied it, they would certainly be poorer for it - but we thankfully value your right to keep your own flesh higher than someone elses abiltiy to be able to feast on it.
Liberty is not some absolute - pretty much every one us would agree that directly harming someone infringes more on their liberty than outlawing it would.
It's not a zero sum game - a lot of our laws centre around reducing our liberty in ways that increases it more in other ways: Making violent crime illegal and backing it up with the willingness to deprive those using violence of liberty is a restriction on all of us, and certainly even more so of those we justifiably lock up for our protection. But one that simultaneously increases our overall liberty by constraining a tool of oppression.
> I'm using an extreme example to demonstrate the absurdity of the argument that enforcing exclusive control over abundant and practically free natural resources
If something is abundant, then the argument doesn't apply. That is the entire point: It applies to scarcity. If something is abundant then everyone who wants it can have access.
But land is one such thing that is distinctly scarce. Suitable farmland even more so.
> deprives others of their rights.
If you starve to death because you can not afford food, much less land to grow a crop, nor afford to move anywhere else, you might think otherwise.
That is not really a hypothetical example. E.g. during the Great Famine in Ireland, Irish food exports increased while hundreds of thousands starved to death because their crops had failed and they could not afford to buy the plentiful amounts of food being exported from the island.
They were deprived of their right to life because others property rights were given precedence - to the extent of the UK giving military escorts to ships exporting food.
Were those who died not deprived?