The way you close off a well is by a) closing either of the valves or b) pumping a few tons of sand and cement down the pipe to block the drilling hole.
Here the top valve failed (with the first explosion) and the bottom valve doesn't work. The pipe broke when the platform sank, and without a connection to the drilling hole the well can't be blocked in the normal fashion. Plus it's too deep underwater for divers or normal submarines.
Without a connection to the well or a working valve, you're basically screwed.
The only certain way to stop the leak at this stage is to drill a new hole at an angle to the first one, a relief well, then you have a connection you can use to pump in the sand and cement to block the well beneath the sea bottom. They have started the process of doing that, the only problem is that it will take months.
Fixes that are known to work in shallower water, like the dome to contain the spill so it could be pumped up, didn't work here - it got clogged up by deep water crystals.
Drilling at these depths is still largely experimental, so there's not much prior experience to draw on.
Maybe they will find a solution at some point, but besides drilling the relief well no fix is know at this time - it's basically trial and error.
There is a giant pipe connecting to regions with liquids in them. Liquid flows from region to the other because that is what nature says it will do. The way you stop the leak is by closing that pipe, without creating any other holes connecting the regions. This pipe did have a shutoff valve for exactly this situation, but it failed and will not activate. So basically your option is to squeeze the steel pipe shut, and hopefully this doesn't weak the pipe causing it to break. Also, apparently the pipe is mostly covered by rock, so somehow you have to work around that.
I'm sure we've all tried to stop the water from coming out of the garden hose by putting a kink in the hose. It's like that, except now you can't reach the hose because it's under lots of rock, and really far under water. You could put your thumb over the top, but there is too much pressure.
I don't see why they'd need to carry the payload in/on the vessels. Couldn't the payload be dropped or lowered from above?
There was one, namely the blowout preventer. It failed
or that can be rapidly put into place in the first few days after the spill starts.
That's much easier said than done when you're talking about oil coming out at high pressure, and uneven topography all at a depth of 1 mile under the ocean.
How was this stuff built up in the first place? (honest question)
The pipeline is formed by drilling long holes (using bentonite slurry to keep the hole from collapsing on itself), building a long pipeline use threaded or welded segments, and slipping the pipe down the whole. It's like well digging, but on a much larger scale.
however, being a software engineer doesn't preclude one from being right or having useful insight within any other realm of human activity.