There's no estate tax upon your death because the assets were already transferred. The assets aren't taxed on transfer, either, but only as they're paid out to the beneficiaries. The effect is as if the original grantor (your great Uncle Gates) was immortal, giving out stipends to his descendants.
You don't hear about this much because the state laws are only a few decades old, but the repercussions play out over generations. It'll become a thing in another 100 years or so when people finally realize what's happening.
Before this the trick was to use corporations. Maybe nominally non-profit, but mostly existing to employ the descendants. That's still a good idea depending on what you're trying to accomplish. Like with trusts you create it in a state with friendly legislation.
It sucks that conservatives are so hell-bent on repealing the estate tax, but it's really not a battle worth fighting over. The war was lost long ago. What nominal revenue the estate tax brings in has been shrinking for awhile, and it'll eventually shrink to nothing.
At this point people are just fighting for an idea. And I literally mean _just_ an idea. Retaining the estate tax won't stop anything, and it might give people a false sense of comfort. Maybe better to let it get repealed, then hope that in a few generations there's enough backlash to not only restore the estate tax, but to foreclose the alternatives as well.
Eight states have repealed the rule against perpetuities.
These states are Alaska (repealed the rule for vesting of
property interests), Delaware (repealed entirely for
personal property interest held in trust; 110 year rule for
real property held directly in trust), Idaho, Kentucky
(repealing the rule interests in real or personal property),
New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Dakota.
Nine states have adopted longer fixed periods for the rule
against perpetuities, sometimes only for certain types of
property. These states are Alabama (100 years for property
not in trust; 360 years for property in trust), Arizona (500
years), Colorado (1,000 years), Delaware (110 years for real
property held in trust); Florida (360 years), Nevada (365
years), Tennessee (360 years), Utah (1,000 years),
Washington (150 years).
Source: http://www.actec.org/assets/1/6/Zaritsky_RAP_Survey.pdf
In those states--even the ones with the absent or absurdly long vesting period limitations--there may be other rules that make it hostile for multi-generational trusts. But I'm pretty sure that in at least a few of them you can do exactly that. But I don't know enough about estate law to be able to point them out without further research. Much like the laws leveraged by lawyers and accountants who help the rich move their money off-shore, they don't generally discuss this stuff in public forums. But it's not nearly as secret or esoteric, so with some effort it should be easy to figure out which states are attracting the most business, so to speak.If you were establishing a multi-generational trust you'd want to put it in a politically, economically, and legally stable jurisdiction. Historically those options were limited to the U.S., U.K., and maybe a couple of other European nations. That's less the case now. But who knows what the world will look like in a 100 years. There's plenty of reason to want to keep money in the U.S. So I wouldn't argue that U.S. law is inconsequential in the face of foreign options. I just don't see us returning to an earlier time wrt restraints on generational wealth transfers. The viability of foreign options makes it even more difficult to reverse the trend.
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_eq...
Can you talk us through what exactly it is that we misunderstand, and what the correction would be?
Control of the distribution of wealth and income is certainly a tricky, multi-faceted challenge that society had to face since the beginning of civilization, and certainly will have to face many a day.
In the US we have a mixed bag of libertarians who think it just and egalitarians who think it unjust. If you ever want to see either the token estate tax ended or the loopholes closed, and not just indefinitely moan over the imperfect world we live in, you have to make your case. Arguing over the estate tax is a reasonable proxy: if you could actually convince people the estate tax was important and necessary, they would also be inclined to believe we should close the loopholes.
In the proposals floating around to repeal the estate tax, there is at least one that suggests repealing the tax entirely but then not giving estates the step up in cost basis.
This has a set of interesting results, including paying no tax until an asset is sold. For instance, if your parents bought at&t stock at $10, and it's worth $20 when you inherit it, you pay no tax. But when you sell it, let's say at $25, you will pay capital gains tax on the difference between the sell price and the _original_ buy price. Estate tax right now gives a step up in the cost basis regardless of whether the tax limit (roughly $10million) is ever hit.
And just to cover the topic, there are two main reasons against the estate tax. The first is that the state has no right to that money. The second, thought, is much more problematic. If you inherit a business, valued at $20 million, you'd have to pay estate tax of roughly $5 million upon your inheritance. If you just owned the at&t stock I referred to above, no big deal - sell some, pay the tax, and walk away with your remaining $15 million.
But if you have a family business, the effects can kill the business. For instance, if your parents own a retail outlet or manufacturing facility, you can't easily sell part of it.
The US has never had an issue with permanent wealth like Europe has, even for the hundreds of years before the estate tax was put in place.
[1]https://taxfoundation.org/estate-and-inheritance-taxes-aroun...
In addition, a large proportion of the "family farms" complaining about the estate tax are sham farms, essentially real-estate investment vehicles that throw a handful of cows on them in order to qualify for farm subsidies and property-tax exemptions. This is an especially popular kind of "family farm" in exurban Texas. There are genuine family farms, but they are much rarer than the number on paper, and typically don't, coincidentally, happen to hold as much prime investment land.
The current estate tax threshold largely misses real family farms, but it doesn't have to move much to become a disaster. When I was in high school I personally witnessed neighbor widdows being beggared by the then ridiculous estate tax threshold. That memory is seared into my brain.