The Zappos Strategy. Get people to tell themselves that they're not really "buying" a toy, they're just going to try it out and then return it and get their money back.
Store credit is meaningless -- that is not a refund.
Free shipping is essential as well. Both ways. Otherwise people are thinking about how much the shipping will cost.
The key is for people to think they can screw the store. They'll try out a toy, return it, and be out no money.
The secret is that most people buy something and either enjoy it enough, or are too lazy, to return it. That's when you win.
The problem is that you need to have enough money/inventory to support the people that do return. Obviously you have to have limits, to minimize abuse.
This costs money though. It may not be a strategy you can afford to pursue.