Methane is more potent than CO2, but fairly short lived. Maybe Mars had more Methane in the distant past? If a 95% CO2 atmosphere isn't enough green house gas for liquid water, I'd assume internal heat played some sort of role.
My guess is methane as well, Mars still "breathes" out methane occasionally[1]. Given that chunks of Mars have been kicked off the planet and landed on Earth, I wonder if you modeled a chunk of Titan's methane ice being kicked off Titan and hitting Mars would have the effect of filling out enough of Mars' atmosphere to warm it.