edit: or do you mean that the overhead of applying optimizations and profiling outweigh the performance gains relative to compiling from something like c directly to machine code?
Profile-guided optimisations win you about 20% in most industrial Java, apparently. So if you have a server that starts, warms up in say 30 seconds, and then runs for a week, you can see that it is easily profitable. For a command line app that lives for 500 msec, not so much.
Not necessarily, especially if you explicitly rely on them.
For example in C++ you deliberately have to avoid overusing virtual functions if you don't want the overhead. In Java, virtual functions are the default, and you usually don't care: if you call them a lot (e.g. in a tight loop) JVM will adaptively give you the proper implementation - without per call indirection - or may even inline it.
If you code C++ in Java style then JVM will win - so the overhead of (runtime) profiling and applying optimizations not always greater
So if G++ is able to tell the code paths leading to the virtual call, it does the same optimization as the JVM.
This is where JIT wins, as it can do that with binary deployed code.
It doesn't seem very popular unfortunately. Most web/tech companies are obsessive about capturing user interaction data for UX purposes, but it would be nice if that data could be fed back into a profile-guided optimizer.
In theory the compiled WebAssembly output would always be optimized for the latest usage trends, provided there were frequent builds. Depending on the product, it may even be possible to classify users into various high-level categories based on their behavior, and serve them a binary that's optimized for their specific use case. The latter's level of specificity probably wouldn't be worth it though.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Profile-guided_optimization
[1] https://unhandledexpression.com/2016/04/14/using-llvm-pgo-in...
Jits can beat C in performance in situations where understanding how the program behaves at runtime influences code generation optimizations.