C's variable definition rules are different from C++'s. gcc happily compiles those two lines, g++ exits with the "redefinition" error.
int i;
at file scope is a tentative definition - if, by the end of the compilation unit, no definition has been seen, one of them will become a definition, otherwise it is just a declaration.On the other hand, this:
int i = 0;
is a definition, and you can't have two of those.