1. Steam receives dozens of releases a day and it's difficult for developers/publishers to make their title stand-out without performing marketing.
2. Author perceives that Steam's display algorithm results in display of outliers (very good/bad).
3. Very low quality titles are released/being sold by Steam.
4. Reviews are a very poor metric as reviewers can be shills or rate content poorly out of pettiness or malice.
5. Author thinks that staff-curated titles are the solution.
My responses:
RockPaperShotgun is a game review site. Reviewing games is how they manage to make ad revenue (well, besides click-bait articles). If the defense is that more content comes out than RockPaperShotgun can review, then RockPaperShotgun should hire more people. If that's cost prohibitive, and there's market demand for it, then why are they asking Steam to do it?
1. Welcome to selling anything.
2. I don't know if this is true; I'm not rejecting this claim, but I'd love to see the data.
3. Quantifying "good enough to sell" is a risky game. I'm okay with spending $5 (most of a beer at a bar) on something kind of buggy if it's amusing for 30 minutes. For someone else, that amount may be double or $0 on principle.
4. If this subproblem gets solved without background checks on reviewers, you have a serious business that Amazon/Yelp/etc would love to buy from you.
5. Beyond catching content that simply _does not do what it says on the box_, this is all personal taste.
And as an aside, there's a "curious" market that exists in low-quality games that have DLC/content that ends up on the Steam Community Market (Steam gets a % of each transaction), so the "how did a broken game end up on Steam?" question has more depth than a casual observer would guess.