If you buy a car and park it directly in front of a fire hydrant and forget about it, then the government will seize your car until such time as you pay your fine, the towing fee and storage fee. If you register a domain in contravention to the agreed contract then ICANN will seize your domain until such time as you correct it (including the time it takes to confirm that you have complied). It really isn't that strange.
seizure and then negotiation is an unnecessary show of force in my opinion, unless the site was doing something criminal
What is unreasonable about requiring accurate and up-to-date contact information for the registrant?
Anyway as I stated originally, I am no fan of ICANN's process here, but currently it is what it is so the responsibility, particularly of superusers, is to understand and have systems in place for compliance. I simply do not buy the "too many domains" and "who uses email" excuses presented in the post.
"i have too many cars, so i shouldn't need to worry about if i park some of them in front of fire hydrants"
i would say that im struggling to understand a situation where the confiscation of a domain or a car is ever warranted, unless something criminal and clearly urgent (a fire, a drug running operation) needs to be stopped, rather than just as bureaucratic overreach to ensure payment and compliance