The picture in the article states:
Avast 11.7: Advertises DES as a cipher (It's been vulnerable for more than a decade)
AVG and Bit Defender: Vulnerable to Logjam and POODLE
Kaspersky: Vulnerable to CRIME
Net Nanny, KinderGate, CYBERsitter, NOD32, Kaspersky Internet Security (Mac): Doesn't validate certificates.
As a more general issue, TLS interception is a problem. Widespread acceptance of TLS proxying violates the TLS contract, which is that all my communications between a website and my browser are safely encrypted.
I completely agree that the current state of affairs is gravely deficient :(
"The researchers urge antivirus vendors to stop intercepting HTTPS altogether, since the products already have access to the local filesystem, browser memory, and content loaded over HTTPS"
I wonder why they are resorting to TLS interception then. Is it just easier to intercept TLS then inspecting memory? Is it just a lack of perspective?
Similarly the "it's how we've always done it" defense because companies have used that approach for HTTP for so long they don't want to invest in a new approach now that HTTPS makes it much less viable.
As for consumer AV products, I have no idea how they defend that other than "let's have our tentacles in all the pies".
They can't (or actually don't) prevent loss of confidentiality.
Companies that run these MITM proxies are also protecting against deliberate extrusion of sensitive data.
Sure. But they also can't be sharing sensitive data with third parties. And yet many AV/security products can upload samples for analysis.[0] Including Word documents.
0) https://www.av-comparatives.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/a...
So you're saying that providers just promise not to disclose? What if they screw up? Who's liable?
Let's say that I'm a freelance developer. Could I get an NDA? And if so, would it cost a lot?
So you need the legal fees to come up with the NDA and sufficient capital to be able to fund a lawsuit should the other party violate the NDA.
Finally, you need to be big enough that the other company is interested in signing an NDA for the business. For a solo developer, this is unlikely to be true.
So then, standalone GPs shouldn't be using AV software.
I've long been of the opinion that for most people anti-virus is ineffective snake oil that significantly compromises PC performance for very little security benefit.
They could just use a whitelist and replace all CAs on the computer with a (set of?) private CA(s) that allow the user to do work on information that requires such security.
Yes, it is possible to explicitly list all certificates you need, or you could simply use the same PK infrastructure as the rest of the world.
I bet 100 years ago it was considered unrealistic to tell white collar employees that they could not bring booze to the office. Today it is a firing offense in most jurisdictions.
After all, people are already aware there is a distinction between their professional personna and their private self. They know there are things you do under one identity but not under the other, and viceversa. Merely adding one tiny thing to the list will do little.
Sure, executives will push back. I bet they pushed back even harder when accountants told them that "No, you cannot put your stripclub bill into the corporate credit card; and I don't care if it was a business expense, either."
That's the meaning of being a professional: telling the higher-ups that there are hard rules (natural or otherwise) that don't give a flying-fuck about their social status. Doctors know it, lawyers know it, accountants know it, but for some reason IT people does not seem able to figure that out. Compensation aside, the social prestige that comes with each of those professions is directly proportional to their ability (and duty) to enforce those standards regardless of what their rich and powerful bosses think about it.
If you attempt to force your lawyer to violate ethics, and their document it and complain then no lawyer will work for you.
If you attempt to force a doctor to violate ethics, then not only will no doctor work for you, but you might actually get jail time.
They don't have it.