Google snooping your WiFi? Don't panic.
blog.hackensplat.com
blog.hackensplat.com
It’s true that you need to have a good understanding of various very technical issues but that’s not a excuse for leaving your viewers (and voters) in the dark and gleefully suggesting that malign intent could be a good explanation for what Google did. What Google did was most likely illegal, it was also a pretty bad screw up on Google’s part but it is very unlikely that Google intentionally recorded the data. That just doesn’t seem like a good explanation.
Why do I (as someone who has some understanding of the technical issues involved but not a very deep one) have to read in blogs about good probable explanations? (I read another very good and quite similar German blog post on the topic [1].) Why don’t I find something like that anywhere else in the media?
(I must say, though, that the German Google spokespeople who were interviewed seemed pretty bad at explaining the issue at hand. Maybe just quote mining, but they didn’t look good in front of the camera.)
[1] http://blog.koehntopp.de/archives/2860-Wie-man-aus-Versehen-... (German)
People in the US, and the media, are extremely sympathetic to major corporations. The European look is entirely the opposite. That's why EU countries have so many wonderfully solid consumer protection laws.
I would perhaps add a comment about how they were scanning about 5 networks per second on average (per Google's blog post that spawned this story), so it's likely that only a fraction of a second of data being transmitted at that particular time was intercepted. A layperson may not even realize that it wasn't the contents of the machines on a wifi network that was being scanned, but a tiny amount of the traffic going across it.
I was just so happy with it I had to post a link here. (I'm so vain. I probably think Hacker News is about me.)