1. AF1 is a 747. If you've never been on a 747 (or A380), then you might not appreciate how smooth landings are in general. It's a lot of airplane with a lot of momentum (not to mention a lot of electronic assistance for the pilots).
2. You say "The notion that the Airforce One pilots are somehow special with special landing skills strikes me as fanciful." I don't consider that notion fanciful at all! In fact, I'd expect they have special landing skills. The AF1 pilots are not just some random commercial or charter pilots, they are Air Force officers, hand-picked from the best of the best. In addition, not only do they have to take-off and land the president's airplane, they also must be able to take evasive action IN A FREAKIN' 747 in the event of a hostile encounter. So "special landing skills"...I'd buy it.
EDIT: Also, reading the original Quora answer, the particular landing mentioned was on the Shuttle Landing Facility, one of the longest runways in the world! I'd wager the pilot could've practically let AF1 roll out the landing and had room to spare.