I was a PhD student in mathematical logic, and I know a couple people who got PhDs in this area and became data scientists. One thing about this field (and other areas of math) is that almost everyone in it feels mediocre. It's like 10% of the people are 10x better than the other 90%, 1% are 10x better than the next 9%, .1% are 10x better than the next .9%, etc. The top two people in the field seem to be notably better than everyone else. Another thing is that the problems are incredibly arcane. They have no connection to practical concerns or even often other parts of math, and also you can't really explain what you are working on to someone who works in a different area of mathematical logic (unless maybe the person is extremely good). So you have a lot of people getting PhDs who are very, very smart by any normal measure but who would be doing mediocre and arcane work in mathematical logic. Part of the appeal of working in data science or working for the NSA or something is that it is somewhat down-to-earth and people will think you are really smart even if you are at the bottom of the top .01%. (And you can do really great work at this level -- I don't mean to say it is all about caring what other people think.) It is a little weird that the blog post is so negative in a way.