For example, surface temperature forecast verification for Jan 2017: http://www.mdl.nws.noaa.gov/~verification/ndfd/index.php?mo_...
I can predict Hawaii's temperatures out 20 years based on historical data much better than Chicago's. So some adjustment for area variability should be accounted for. People also care a lot more based on how off the temperatures are. So, being off by 5 degrees every day is better than being off by 1 degree for 4 days then 20 for the 5th.
I assume there is some adjustments for this stuff?
I remember flying on one day when the forecast said that I'd be able to climb to 3,000ft in one spot, and to 6,000ft in another spot only about five miles away. In the air, I tried the first spot because it looked better to me. I topped out at 3,000ft. I moved over to the second spot and sure enough, 6,000ft. It was pretty amazing how good that one was.
Due to the banding, you can get extreme variations in snowfall, leading to, "I thought we were supposed to get a foot, but we only got an inch!" type of comments. Or, bands will line up with the storm motion and just pelt an area harder than expected.
Example: http://imgur.com/i0j4I7g
http://blogs.mprnews.org/updraft/2017/02/snowcover-view-from... - under "GFS model shifted". They do similar articles semi regularly.
But in the big picture sense, and for things like hurricanes, forecasting has improved a lot. It's unlikely we'd be caught by surprise today as happened with the Blizzard of '78 when massive numbers of cars got stuck on the highway and had to be abandoned or people were stuck at their offices for a week. (The weather events still occur of course but they're less likely to catch people unprepared.)
It's probably less true than it used to be but, for years, a lot of people in Boston were really paranoid about big snow storms. Everyone knew someone or at least knew someone who knew someone who had be evacuated from Route 128 or slept in their office for a week.
About a decade later a friend of mine moved to Boston and she once told me that she had never seen a northern city where people took off home from work at the first snowflake the way they did in the Boston area.
My girlfriend is from Florida, and even after three years of living here she is still unused to the habit of keeping ice scrapers, umbrellas, rain boots and an extra jacket in the car at all times.
Upstate weather is a mystery. When I was in school we had 80 degree weather towards the end of the spring semester before a small snowfall the day before graduation.