Is this the offending language?
>If you set your pages and repositories to be viewed publicly, you grant each User of GitHub a nonexclusive, worldwide license to access your Content through the GitHub Service, and to use, display and perform your Content, and to reproduce your Content solely on GitHub as permitted through GitHub's functionality. You may grant further rights if you adopt a license.
Is the theory here that this negates FOSS licenses, over-riding copyleft terms with permissive terms?
Based on my reading, it comes down to whether your read the "use, display and perform" as conjunct or disjoint with "solely on Github." If it is conjunct, it should not be a problem. If it is disjoint... yeah, that may be a problem.
To be explicitly clear, I am a software lawyer and I write a whole hell of a lot of licenses that have to play well with FOSS licenses. I do this for a living.
I am going to have to think this over pretty hard.
Edit: I just tweeted at them: https://twitter.com/LibertyMcateer/status/837048904583626752
I'll post more if I hear anything.
Edit edit: read this response: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13766933
I am persuaded. The pertinent language, for "use, display and perform" is pretty limited. Typically, copyleft licenses are hinged on the distribution of code - which is basically the same thing as reproduction in the digital world. A general license to use, display and perform code may play well with copyleft licenses as a result.
Disclaimer: I am not your lawyer. I am not github's lawyer. These statements are my own, not my firm's and I have not performed a full analysis of this language or GitHub's license. If you need a legal opinion, you should retain a lawyer.