There were differently thought-out solutions, but not necessarily better or worse. Perhaps the issues they thought out didn't matter as much at the time and very unlikely to matter even a little bit today, and who knows how much they got wrong and much worse. It's very hard to speculate. But one thing I'm sure of is that these things cannot be really well designed from scratch and all the problems manifest only once they are used by people. So widely used systems can only be compared to widely used systems, not something niche or unused.