Suggest HN: Saving articles feature request | Hacker News Reader

Suggest HN: Saving articles feature request

6 pointsredcap10 comments

I really like HN, technical articles with little or no bullshit tolerated. However, there are often so many good articles that appear for a couple of days and then vanish into the nether. I've been making good use of the Save Article feature on the nytimes iPhone app, and was wondering if there could be a similar feature added to HN. With the amount of good links floating around (as well as the useful commentary), I believe this would be a good addition.

On the other hand, does anyone have any suggestions on how to manage good links/articles? I occasionally hear Read it Later mentioned, and there are bookmark sites such as del.icio.us. I do find that saving good links locally as a bookmark often means that it goes into a black hole as I just don't organise my bookmarks any more.

View on HN

Click on the name of your profile at the top right, then click 'saved stories'.

I think I get that - any story that I upclicked or commented is a "saved story"?

It's nice to have I guess, but not really the stories that I explicitly wanted to save. I upmark HN stories that I think other people would be interested in reading, which is not explicitly the stories that I want to save and maybe refer to them later - that would be a much smaller subset.

Ok. Well, I can't make that happen for you, but better this much smaller set to look through than the one of 'all urls' right ?

I upvote that which I would possibly want to re-visit so for me it works just fine.

I'll upvote anything, me! Well, near enough to.

It's a smaller list, sure but the first two pages only went back 29 days - I can remember a post several months back being very useful, no idea how long it would take me to find it again.

If there was some way to get the whole list of links I've upvoted it might make things easier, and if I could cull it down too that would help if I could drastically cut down my upvotes.

Another options is 'diigo', formerly furl.net

And if you use diigo, confirm that something's been saved by looking in your Library. I've used it since it was FURL. And I've found the diigo bookmarklet will claim something has been saved when it hasn't.

Hey, that's weird. I've used them a lot and never saw that, did you file a bug report with them ?

No. How can I ever reproduce that? It's only recently I noticed that things I knew I saved weren't there when I did a Search for them. Now I always call up my Library to confirm.

I have a posterous account that I use to keep links I want to revisit later. It's really nice since you can email links to make posts.

I use ReadItLater in my browser and on my iPhone to keep track of stories I'm interested in.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com