Wikipedia and Inherent Open Source Bias
contentini.com
contentini.com
The article suggests that this should be fixed by making wikipedia easier to edit, allowing people who can't quite grok the complexities of the existing interface or difficult guidelines like "Verifiability" to make their own entries. I am extremely unconvinced that this would raise the overall quality of wikipedia.
Overall I think there are two schools of thought about wikipedia. I join the school of thought which thinks it's like a dog walking on its hind legs: instead of complaining that it's doesn't work perfectly we should be amazed that it's done at all. This guy seems to be in the school of thought that thinks the dog might walk a lot further if we gave it shoes.
Not at all: what I'm saying is that it would be better if it had a more diverse, representative audience contributing to it. That just makes sense. Why wouldn't you want older, more experienced people contributing to an encyclopedia? Or women!??
I agree that given the current complexities of the system, a wider audience would currently not be able to easily improve the quality - there would be plenty of mistakes. But this is the fundamental problem, and some would say responsibility, that Wikipedia now faces.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Systemic_bias
The origins of Wikipedia's bias
The average Wikipedian on the English Wikipedia is (1) a man, (2) technically inclined, (3) formally educated, (4) an English speaker (native or non-native), (5) white, (6) aged 15–49, (7) from a majority-Christian country, (8) from a developed nation, (9) from the Northern Hemisphere, and (10) likely employed as a white-collar worker or enrolled as a student rather than employed as a labourer.[1]
They've got various projects to counter this imbalance and it all seems worthwile. I'm glad to see coverage of things like the Second Congo War (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Congo_War) which were mere stubs when I first looked at them have been thouroughly fleshed out.
I will say though, that no matter how many non-white, blue-collar, elderly woman from developing nations sign up for Wikipedia I doubt many will be interested in baby-sitting a list of Content Management Systems.
For example, check out the history of the PivotX listing mentioned in the article: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=PivotX&action=... - although it was flagged as 'non notable', it got away with staying on the list just by deleting the 'spam' flag and saying 'but we're not a blatant advert' (but not dealing with the notability argument at all). After that, nothing has been said.
Compare that with the attention that Ektron (a well known proprietary system) received: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion...
The writer points out that many editors are not university educated like this means that their edits are of less worth than those with a degree. That's laughable.
To summarize: more FUD aimed at Wikipedia.