Sort of my point. You may think you only hire good people, but by comparison you are hiring middle of the road. Thus, you clearly don't know what a top 1% engineer looks like.
I was being tongue-in-cheek with my first post, but I do think there is a flipside to what you say in the OP. If the people giving interviews are 25 and have only had one job since they graduated, they may mistake an unfamiliar way of doing things as incompetence.