The top 5 things I look for in an application are (in no particular order):
1) Can the team clearly communicate what they are working on?
2) Does the team have the technical talent to build and grow the v1 of their product?
3) Is the team moving quickly or are they waiting for approval from YC?
4) Did the founders have a personal or professional relationship before deciding to start the company together?
5) Does the team understand something about their space that is controversial or non-obvious?