Really now, this "solution" boils down to "assume the existence of insurance companies that act radically differently from any insurance companies we have experience with"...tis much like "now, assume a can opener".
1. they do carry insurance. Their fuel assets are insured by Jupiter Insurance ltd. ( a wholly owned subsidiary of...BP itself. According to their annual report, they consider external insurance a poor economy and carry as little as possible - basically $1 billion per incident, figuring that any overages can be paid for out of revenues. Awesome.
http://www.bp.com/liveassets/bp_internet/globalbp/STAGING/gl...
2. OK, so make them carry more insurance...but then you're back to the dead hand of government regulation or whatever you want to call it. And with the best will in the world, sometimes events take place which are beyond our ability to predict. I imagine the government's recent cautious endorsement of more offshore drilling was based on a careful look at the number of rig disasters in recent years, and the assumption that the industry was sufficiently mature to appreciate the importance of risk management. It's kind of ironic that this occurred right after Obama upset the 'ban all drilling' crowd.