I don't see how this is different than having circumstantial evidence that someone is a murderer, so ordering them to lead you to where they buried the body.
I don't see how this is different than having circumstantial evidence that someone is a murderer, so ordering them to lead you to where they buried the body.
Sounds like the only right answer for your password is "I do not recall"
Sure, but that's not the case here. They apparently already know he possesses a certain number of such photos, and now are now trying to compel him to incriminate himself further.
1. They don't have enough evidence to convict, and know it, and thus are waiting for this evidence. The problem here being a question of how are they sure enough of guilt to hold him in jail for so long.
2. They do have enough evidence to convict, but they rather have a precedent destroying (or weakening) encryption. This would be like the San Bernardino iPhone case.
I'm not sure which possibility is worse.