Ask HN: Are large corporations with fraudulent IT managers the norm?
Edit: can we name the bad ones, so that other developers dont have their careers damaged and hard work wasted?
Edit: can we name the bad ones, so that other developers dont have their careers damaged and hard work wasted?
It makes good sense to hold back a good worker so that they keep doing good work, instead of spending a quarter on learning a new job.
It makes sense to put a ok(maybe bad) worker in a differnt position to see if they do better. Often seen as a promotion by others even if it's not.
In a normal workplace you don't just fire your bottom 5% each year without having chilling effects on your workforce. You move them around and see if they're capable elsewhere, and can use their knowledge/contacts in other parts of the company to have an advantage over a new hire.
This is absolutely not limited to large companies in any way.
What makes me look askance at this practice as a whole is when the ok/bad people are put in charge of the good workers. I've been a part of and heard of other teams (in my case specifically as a trench-software worker) being run into the ground by someone cross promoted and given serious control w/o oversight and minimal leadin.
Obviously that's anecdotal at best, but I've seen it in my corner as extremely common.
Good managers are hard to find. People don't quit their job, they quit their boss.
I think it is an adequate tl;dr for this whole thread...
I had bad experience in my last company and have decided to stay away from any companies where there are 5 or more people between CEO & the lowest level engineer.
If there are many layers of management then it is a sure shot indication that there will be too much politics within the company and it would be hard to grow unless you start playing the game. Also, it also means the people who you work with and managers will be indulging in unnecessary office politics.