Could you imagine being governed the way that your 500-year-old elders deem fitting? We wouldn't need violent extremists to try to reimpose 16th century public morals. They would simply never have left.
To support this, you have to believe we are perfect now, that there are no more controverises between the young and the old that the young need to win. Otherwise, this is one of those moments where society pulls up the drawbridge, comes full circle. We'll have leaned so far into science and technology that the next time the elders cry "Witchcraft!" they will never go away.
When will religion die out? In time to save the religious from persecution?
I wish I could agree with your rosy outlook, but my view of a realistic form of immortality is in line with Richard K. Morgan's vis a vis 'Altered Carbon'. People keep looking for a technology to change us as humans, but we're going to have to do it ourselves, and soon, or die. Technology doesn't change our nature, it just empowers us to act more freely on it.
Right now life is so short that by the time you barely start getting a grasp of what's going on, it's already time to go.
Our current course ends in death, not immortality.
The only thing that needs a positive attitude and a suspension of disbelief is fraud.
150,000 people die every day. That's bigger than a moderate-sized city. That's not a problem to casually get around to maybe thinking about in the perpetual "a few years from now but really never"; that's a problem we should be devoting a substantial part of our total resources to.
Other medical research has helped prevent people from dying early and that's certainly worth continuing. But that's not what we're discussing here.
I understand that this is something that's almost impossible to accept though.
Yes, I agree with that strongly. In fact, this is a fear of mine - we're pretty much on the verge of quality-changing breakthroughs for life itself, and yet it can all go to hell if we fuck up the next few decades over petty issues like profits and power.
I'll go further and say that IMO the most important goal right now in solving any kind of sociopolitical issue should be stability of technological civilization. This should come first before anything - because if we last a bit longer, we might be able to solve other issues long-term, and if we fuck up now, there won't be a technological civilization for the next couple thousand (if not million) years.
- its an accident - they want some sort of benefit, e.g. farm help or gov assistants - biological urges
Making people immortal wouldn't affect any of those. Which do you think is worse for the poor who tend to rush into kids: a lifetime of poverty, or an eternity of it?
No it's not. Idealistic is to have the masses wise and involved enough to get rid of persistent leader-castes. This sort of getting-rid is likely to happen quite soon, especially if we in the masses hear that the leader-caste are likely to become immortal while we remain subject to the Reaper.
It's morbid to say it but I have no reservations in admitting that I(and I'll throw out there most others I know) am looking forward to these people "moving on".
And by "moving on" I mean dying and getting out of the way.
On top of that, we had an extremely progressive candidate running; his name was "Bernie", and he was older than both Hillary and Donald. He was far more progressive than "young" Obama, and he was also very popular with the youngest voters. You don't have to be young to be popular with young people, and think in idealistic ways like younger people.
I don't want to see these people die of old age; I'd rather keep great old people like Bernie around. If the people of our country are so stupid that they keep electing people like Hillary and Trump and rejecting people like Bernie, then they deserve that kind of governance.
> "How fortunate that science hasn't cracked human immortality. It's a great blessing that we can outlive old wars. And old warriors."
-- Komarr by Lois McMaster Bujold
The human race is like a giant fuzzing machine, we just try everything, push every boundary, bad and good, and see what happens.
But, our lives are too short for the lessons to last very long, and we repeat our mistakes relatively frequently. We try to encode some of the lessons into social structures, from religion to literature to law, to pass onto future generations.
But I can't help but wonder how things would be in this regard if we all just lived an order of magnitude longer. Less war? Fewer financial collapses?
I also wonder if less innovation too, but I imagine if the great inventors of our time lived 10x longer we'd get more rather than less, given that it takes an increasingly large portion of a lifetime to learn enough of our growing body of scientific knowledge to be able to make real contributions to it.
We are in a world that has stretched overall life expectancy by dozens of years already in the past 100 years. Humans have not changed THAT much for it.
however, you're still absolutely right that senescence is inevitable and we have very little, besides nutrition and exercise, that can do anything about it.