Data from the recording industry lawsuits, revealed in a court case, showed that 11,000 of the 18,000 Does settled immediately or had their cases dropped by the labels
And:
Dunlap, Grubb, & Weaver generally asks for $1,500 to $2,500, threatening to sue for $150,000 if no settlement payment is forthcoming. Assuming that 90 percent of the current targets settle for $1,500, this means that the lawyers, studios, and P2P detection company would split $19.7 million.
I accept that I could be missing something here and would welcome enlightenment from someone better informed than me, but I find it difficult to believe that the lawyers have downloaded 18,000 copies (i.e. one for each John Doe) of the infringing material.
Without doing this, how can they have a case that actually stands up in court, and one that successfully proves that the John Doe actually made the material available? Surely it would only take a few hundred people to successfully challenge them for the profits to be lost?