A/B Testing + Clickmaps = Awesomeness
visualwebsiteoptimizer.com
visualwebsiteoptimizer.com
Replacing that with a link to a video seems to miss the point - people are clearly interested in a specific kind of information (pricing, commitment costs - the main potential deal breaker) and by making this change - you're still not giving it to them. Now maybe you want to try and hook people in the belief that if it looks cool enough, that'll override what would have been a problematic price point - that, of course, would be a much more interesting A/B test - up front pricing or concealed...
Replacing 'Sign up' with 'Video' makes sense because the pricing link is still there. So visitors who want to see pricing can go there directly. What we observed was that the homepage doesn't convey full potential of the tool so putting up a video link probably helps those visitors who aren't that price conscious.
Of course, this then gets in to price differentiation - there may be an argument to say that you could have two sites, one more "enterprise" focused, where features and capability are primary, and the price is high, and one more focused around lower level users, making the price a key selling point.
The reason people (myself included) click Pricing is because they want to know what they’re getting themselves into before starting a free trial. I suspect that if you added the pricing clearly on the homepage, the # of clicks on your ‘free trial’ button would increase and pricing would decrease dramatically.
This is covered in the book ‘Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion’ where the author describes a man refusing a flower from a little girl because he’s “on to her game.” The idea being that people have become conditioned NOT to accept free things without understanding the ramifications of signing up – “What if I like it? What happens then? Do I have to pay $600?”
I have noticed this affecting my signups for web apps lately. For example, ZenDesk looks great but the 30 day trial won’t help my company in its infancy. I would love to use a ‘free single user’ version and would gladly pay eventually, but I click pricing and see that after my 30 day trial expires, I’m stuck paying much more than I’m comfortable with. So I haven’t signed up yet. Again, GetSatisfaction is similar. I would like to use their service but before clicking ‘Signup’ I click Pricing to see what I’m getting myself into. What happens if I get hooked? Am I going to be out $200/month?
This is the question I asked myself with your software and your pricing is reasonable. I will definitely sign up when my company launches our product.
So, we are trying to be transparent: telling visitors what the tool does and then what it costs. No gimmicks :)
On the one hand, this is a beautiful advertisement in the style of a blog entry. But on the other hand, this unity between blog entry and ad is a bit scary.
I believe that advertising should be exactly like this: Inform you of a product, tell you what value it can offer you, then allow you to make an informed choice.
Advertising is only evil when it is deceptive.
... or when it isn't clearly visible as such. However, this one indeed seems to be labeled clearly enough. Still it looks like a personal user report at a first glance, and that's kind of scary.
That doesn't strike me as abnormal. In fact, if hypothetically a multi-billion dollar multinational advertising firm did not routinely dogfood its own A/B testing service, I would consider that a strike against them.
No, it is a corporate usage report. It is just the writing style that makes it look "personal".
This difference may be subtle, but it is important, because it has a huge impact on how trustworthy the information is. And finding the right level of trust for various information is exactly what makes the difference between an informed user and a persuaded user.
(BTW, it is of course very positive that they make use of their own product, and this is certainly not what I'm criticizing.)
It is socially accepted that companies may speak about their products in a onesided, strongly biased way, called "advertisement". This is in contrast to balanced, objective reports as expected from e.g. journalists and scientists. And it is also in contrast to honest, uninfluenced personal opinions as expected from e.g. friends and blogs.
In return, those "advertisements" are expected to be explicitly labeled as such, or to be so exaggerated that they are obviously visible as such. That's how we try to ensure fairness.
In a sense this is the case here, because the "blog entry" is shown under your website's domain. On the other hand, it is a user report of someone (i.e. you) who is using and testing your software, where one usually expects the honest and uninfluenced personal opinion of a user.
It is okay as it is. But if you changed one detail, it wouldn't be okay anymore. (e.g. write about another website rather than your own, or put it into another blog at another domain, or remove the exaggeration in the title as well as the text.)
So it is scary, because it is close to the border. But I think it is still on the "good" side of the border, not on the "evil side".
However, I agree that this is complaining on a high level.