Unfortunately it is #2. I am underpaid by over 75%. The average on the team is under by about 30 - 50%... so not only am I underpaid I am underpaid quite a lot more than others in the company. I do, however, have quite a bit more stock options.
And the CEO from what I understand went two years without a paycheck. But he is independently wealthy (I am not).
I stay for various personal reasons. Reasons that the other people on the team don't have.
And because 75% underpaid is still enough to support me and my family with a modest lifestyle.