I thought so as well. My doc and I are currently locking horns over this, as my Vit D levels are normal now. Initially this doc was quite helpful (and he spotted the Vit D deficiency- definitely a novel experience for me), but now he's very defensive and saying things like "which one of us has a medical degree?" when I ask about the Vitamin D again.
I honestly can't recall if the initial improvement when taking D started to subside before or after starting the 50K prescription.