>why do people (at least here on HN) stick with it despite these major issues?
Before I switched to lastpass, I had maybe 10 different passwords I shared across 100 sites. This was terrible, and now that I use Lastpass, every password is unique. So I use Lastpass because its an incremental improvement.
Is 1Password an incremental improvement over lastpass? I'm not convinced. It might be a tiny bit more secure, but nowhere near the gain in security I had from 10 re-used passwords -> all unique randomly generated 20+ char passwords. The cost of switching is high and so it would have to be enough of an improvement to justify the switchover.