So the pilot isn't using his senses to decide what to do or his reflexes to control the plane. Why is the pilot in the plane?
So the pilot isn't using his senses to decide what to do or his reflexes to control the plane. Why is the pilot in the plane?
At the time they were the antidote to the "Bomber Mafia." However as time went on the ethos of the pilot and "airmanship" as the most important aspect of the Air Force continued to dominate.
That said, there is an argument to be made for pink and squishy still in the cockpit - though too long to argue here and I'm not the right person to do it. However if anything, the amount that the AF has dedicated to UAV/RPA/UCAS operations over the last decade has really shown that if it works, the AF will do it regardless of where the flight control monkeys (derisive term for pilots) physically sit.
I'd say that reason alone warrants a pilot.
Hint: it's squishy, on average less than two meters tall, and riding in the cockpit.
Now granted, that can technically be done from outside the airplane, but if contact with the plane is lost for any reason, you lose that bit of wetware seated at the helm.
I agree with this, but this wasn't your original point.
Because of latency. I have read several articles about drone pilots. The latency is a really big issue, the biggest of all.
Because of limited bandwidth.
Because of jamming.
Because pilots care better for the multimillion$ equipment if their life is also at stake. (This being the least important)
Because while human life is at stake military and political leaders think twice before starting a war and sending in the fighters/bombers.
* Manned space flight, e.g. putting a man on Mars, is going to catch the public's attention more than unmanned flight, and IMO anything which helps popularise the sciences is generally a good thing.
* Human space flight is a goal in itself. People have been exploring the Earth for centuries despite the risks, so exploring space (in person) is just an extension of that. There also may come a time where living off-planet may be necessary, or at least desirable, so having the knowledge to do so may be useful.
The best-case scenario for manned space flight in our lifetime is that we go to Mars. Robot probes, on the other hand, can go to some wild places in the solar system, including places that would be lethal to a human crew. And they do so at 1% of the cost of manned missions.
I'd wager the excitement per dollar spent is higher for robot probes.
People cheered for the man landing on the moon, all over the world, even in the communist block, despite loosing the space race with that very event. Why? Because it was about people! Because the even the ordinary people could relate to the event.
Think about here on Earth. You can get high definition photo and video from anywhere on the planet. But people still love to travel. Because it's no substitute for the real thing.
The reason why the post-Apollo space program has been so uninspiring is that the only part of Dr. von Braun's vision we actually brought to fruition was the least inspiring part that still went outside the atmosphere - and that only because the Air Force signed on, needing spy satellite mechanics and finding it cheaper to chip in on someone else's otherwise doomed program than to fund a novel one of their own.
Of course, now they can use a robot in that role, and do. No reason to spend any more money on a boondoggle of a space truck, so now our best hope of resuming manned spaceflight rests with a couple of creepy, etiolated billionaires. For someone raised in the vision of Dr. von Braun, to describe this state of affairs as merely dispiriting is to beggar language.
By now we might have been living in orbit and on the moon - we might have been sending men and women to Mars, and preparing to establish our first colonies there. Instead, we fill our sky with robots tending robots and send robots as proxies to mail us their snapshots of the solar system's wonders, while we stay at home - because to do otherwise would cost too much, and besides, someone might get hurt.
If you can manage to find that inspiring, you're welcome - and also quite rare.
Also a lot of the ISS work is experiments, each with their own setup and criteria.
Obviously at some point this will be solved, but there is still the point of having humans in more places than just the Earth.
One of the odder requirements for experiments in the Shuttle was that they had to require human interaction. NASA didn't want to send a spaceship full of astronauts up to babysit fully automated experiments.