Futurism is an extremely useful exercise as long as it's treated as a thought experiment based on current trends rather than actual prognostication.
The median HN post is probably wiser or better informed than the median post to Slashdot or /r/programming or whatever, but at the end of the day it's still an Internet forum for anonymous tech enthusiasts, with all of the potential for bias and tunnel vision that that implies. You still have to wade through mountains of garbage to find gems of insight, there's just sometimes a little less garbage and a little more insight here than elsewhere. I don't say that to cast shade on HN, rather I think accomplishing something like "a little less garbage than proggit" is a freaking miracle and that's why I read HN every day.
Most of us tend to anthropomorphize (or hivemind-ize?) the community, but it's divided on just about every controversial question.