Seems to me that allowing science to win out in the 'market of ideas' is the healthiest solution.
But the inherent humility and uncertainty of rigourous science is often no match for snake oil and demagoguery, as we know.
In the long run, maladaptive beliefs will die out and useful ones will survive, head start or no.
As to what should win out: Truth is a fine ideal to work towards, but one should never expect that it's what will actually win. "Should" is like "deserves". They're nice to think about, but not always realistic.
For Americans, this is shocking (it was to me). "I can't homeschool my own children?!? That isn't freedom!" But in practice, the vast majority of homeschoolers are evangelical christians or other religious extremists. For the good of society, I would gladly take that trade.
Think about this another way: in the US, homeschool parents can impart any view they want on their children. They "win by default" because there are no competing viewpoints. In the EU, parents are still free to try and impart their beliefs on their children. But in this case, they need a stronger argument than what the school is providing. They will not "win by default" like in the US. I can't see anything "unfree" about that.
I think my point is still valid though, especially because in many of those countries, yearly inspections are mandatory (unlike the US).
The inspections ensure that your parents can't fuck up your life. I think it's a good middle ground between allowing everything and nothing.
But, think of it in terms of the original argument. Are you still "free" if you are forced to teach what the state wants? The OP would say no, I think.
Sometimes homeschooling is just better because the public school system isn't very good.
Pretty sure this is wrong. You can homeschool your children, as long as they pass an exam every year (or every 6 months maybe), to prove that their knowledge/skills are good enough (e.g. at least at the level of a public school attendee of the same age).
So while I agree that there is no alternative better than the market-place of ideas; that's still compatible with saying its morally wrong to indoctrinate your children with falsehoods.
Being sloppy about your beliefs -- i.e. just going with your gut and not questioning -- is OK when it's just yourself. But maybe you should only teach kids about the things you have considered more carefully.
It's not an alternative, it's what happens now, and will always happen, unless there is some major disruption in education.
I don't expect most HackerNews readers to agree with that argument (I am of two minds on it) but I would hope it recommends to them a bit of intellectual humility.
Don't think too hard about that one.
You might end up a nietzschean catholic, like me on Tuesdays.
The entire adult population is conspiring to lie to children, and it's up to the child to challenge it based on their own logic and observations.
It's a way to teach children to not trust authority blindly and to develop their own critical thinking skills.
I never felt betrayed by my parents about it. I remember feeling proud that I figured it out, and when my mother told me that everyone did it as a way to honor the memory of the real Saint Nicolas, I understood that.
The truth is just a Google search away now. I wonder if the Santa myth will recede into history for my kid's generation.