Apple says no Internet for those younger than 17
ajaimk.com
ajaimk.com
The 17+ warning is just that—a warning, an indemnificatory disclaimer against lawsuits by angry parents—and only takes effect as a restriction if you switch on parental controls, which also, indeed, exist for Safari itself.
(The "game" part is indeed an oversight—I imagine Apple just never considered that they could be publishing anything other than games that had "mature themes", seeing as 99% of Apps are things like invoice trackers and color swatch wheels, and don't really have "themes" of any kind.)
In fact, Safari can be blocked through the Parental Controls on the iPhone.
If they're based in the US, maybe, but there is more to the Internet than just the US.
(I'm not sure this is an actual law, though. My guess is that it's a defensive measure against "won't someone PLEASE think of the children" and the resulting legislation. Self-regulation and self-preservation.)
> If they're based in the US, maybe, but there is more to the Internet than just the US.
I just think it's Apple acting overly prude like banning US political cartoons etc. Being sued because your web browser has access to adult web sites doesn't make sense. Countries where those sites are illegal are already censoring those sites (China, Malaysia etc).
It's a much better solution than back when they were outright rejecting any application that could access arbitrary content on the internet.
Ever heard of parental controls? That’s what this is for.
More fine-grained parental controls would certainly be nice. But what exactly is your hypothesis here? Apple wants to force parents to submit to their ideas of parenting through their design of the parental controls feature on the iPhone? That seems like a pretty stupid hypothesis to me.
It’s not that the parental controls feature is unworthy of discussion. I don’t think it’s particularly well designed. It just seems so completely absurd and ridiculous to claim that bad design must imply that Apple doesn’t want teenagers to surf the web. I’m utterly confused as to how a story like this can get more than forty upvotes on HN.
It looks like they do actually, forbidding +17 year old to access the web.
> It just seems so completely absurd and ridiculous to claim that bad design must imply that Apple doesn’t want teenagers to surf the web.
How is that bad design? It clearly states that you must be more than 17 year old to access the web.
This age limit only matters if parental controls are enabled. You can then pick which apps can be used, based on their age limit (all of them, only 17+, …). Some OS apps like Safari get extra switches – you can explicitly decide whether Safari and a few other things can be used or not.
Age limits are not always the best solution, though (what some parents deem appropriate, others do not). That’s why I think the parental controls are badly designed. Ideally you would get a switch for every app, so that you can override the age based defaults. Such a list would still be pretty horrible from a UI point of view – all your apps replicated in one unstructured list – that’s probably why Apple doesn’t do it. Or maybe they just had no time to implement that feature, yet. Either way, it’s no big deal.
How would you rate a browser, know that you know how the iPhone’s parental controls work? You can access content with it that a vast majority of parents would consider 17+.
(By the way, how do parental controls work on Android? I’m really curious!)
Thanks I know how it works, no matter how you put it, limiting browsing the net to +17 year old is ridiculous and actually bad, the internet is the greatest resource for students.
> By the way, how do parental controls work on Android? I’m really curious!
There is none, and that's the way it should be, parental control should be done by... parents, not Steve Jobs. If you have porn addictions like this guy you can still remove the browser, youtube and marketplace apps though: http://www.google.com/support/forum/p/Android+Market/thread?...
Edit: parental control is password protected on the iPhone, but it can be undone by a reset of the phone, which any kid can do, so it's pretty useless anyway.
Parental control is done by parents, they're merely given tools. If parents don't want those tools, they can just opt not to use them.
As far as I know children are still legally allowed to see R rated movies with parental consent. I think this is analogous.
Apple is simply giving parents the tools to put these restrictions in place if they choose to.
Unfortunately we live in a world where a small subset of people will seize on any opportunity to blame a company for some sort of indiscretion - in this case, letting their kids access porn (or whatever).
It's just legal ass covering which >99% of people, sensibly, ignore.
No news here.
EDIT: in iTunes I now see "application" not "game". So either they fixed it or it was a bug for some users.
It's likely opera's idea
If it is intentional they're just dumb.