Why do you guys continue to live with it instead of repealing or fixing it?
Why do you guys continue to live with it instead of repealing or fixing it?
The complexity of VAT in Europe is recent.
(I think) it used to be the case that if you sold something from one European country to another, then you weren't subject to VAT because it was considered an "export". Foreign companies (esp. US-based ones like Amazon) exploited this loophole so much, it became a problem. All they had to do was set up shop in a small, low-tax country [1] (Luxembourg / Ireland) and sell in every other country tax-free.
So the EU created this rule that the VAT that should be paid, is the VAT of the country where the customer resides -- it had to be, because if it was the VAT of the seller's country then companies would have again clustered in the country with the lowest VAT in order to evade the new rule.
It's not a bad rule; if you're a huge corporation, well, maybe you don't like it but you can hire the necessary lawyers and accountants to implement it.
If you're an SMB that sells across Europe, it's absolutely horrible. I guess the bureaucrats who wrote the rule didn't care much about SMBs or thought there were few who sold internationally.
It would be simple to exonerate SMBs based on their revenue (and I think it's the case, but the triggers are very low and different in every country); it would be even simpler to have just one tax rate but that's politically impossible.
In practice it doesn't seem to be very much enforced for small companies.
- - -
[1] Low corporate tax, to optimize taxes even further; no need to be based in a low-tax country to free oneself from VAT; the smaller the country the better, because you want to have as few of your customers in the same country as you, as possible.
The end effect is the same: the consumer ends up paying whatever % the tax is. The difference is in how it's collected. Sales tax is easier to evade because business-to-business sales usually don't charge sales tax. So you could wink at your customer and say they're a business and not charge them sales tax. With VAT everyone is supposed to pay it, so it's harder to evade (and consequently more expensive for governments to collect).
Now, what is unnecessarily complicated about VAT in Europe is the presence of very many exemptions. So rather than just doing the same paperwork for every good you sell, you have to consult a database to figure out that you should pay a reduced rate for good X or no VAT at all for good Y. This was done in the name of fairness to the poor — it doesn't seem right to tax essentials like staple foods or hygiene products. But arguably, it would have been much simpler to grant the poor an income tax break sufficient to cover the VAT they are likely to pay for such goods.
One of the things regulators want from a tax code is to stop large companies picking their jurisdiction to avoid sales tax, and therefore gain an unfair advantage. The MOSS is really annoying for microbusinesses, like musicians wanting to sell their album online, but compliance is easily handed off to an accountant for anyone working on such things full-time.
Also, every EU member state already had VAT and already had differing rates and rules before joining the EU, so the complexity was already there.
VATmoss has been disastrous for small online UK businesses.
UK businesses do not have to register for VAT until their turnover exceeds a figure (£80,000 odd).
with VATmoss: if they have any EU customers they must either VAT register in the UK (which adds 20% to their UK prices), OR register and fill out VAT returns for each member state they have customers in, which is not really feasible
I have simply stopped selling to EU customers... "single market", yeah right.
The EU commission's answer to this has been "we know this is a problem for small businesses. we'll sort it out when we discuss it in 2019"... not good enough.
all this bureaucracy was an attempt to try and get Amazon to pay their fair share of VAT... to hell with the small businesses
While I'm sympathetic to the fact that this will increase your administrative burdens, in terms of your bottom line this really won't make much of a difference, because once you register for VAT you can also deduct it for all the costs you make – you only pay tax on the value you add, hence the name.
Thanks for the correction re: the UK not having VAT before joining the union, didn't know that.
Might it affect your profitability? Definitely possible. But it won't eat up 20% of your revenue or require you to charge 20% more to break even.
- £10,000 to produce a infinitely reproducible widget -> costs of £10,000
- sell 5,000 times for £10 -> income £50,000
profit of £40,000with VAT:
- £10,000 to produce a infinitely reproducible widget, all allowable, 20% VAT back -> costs of £8,000
- sell 5,000 times for £10 - (approx) £2 VAT -> income of £40,000
now I have a profit of £32,000 insteadif I'm selling mostly domestically the logical conclusion is to no longer sell to non-domestic EU customers
At that point, 5000 widgets at 10 net = 50000 - 8000 net costs = 42000 -> as a business, if your costs include VAT, you're actually better off by opting in. Sure, you feel the pain when you first transition (which is why you should have started with it right away), the first couple of years the taxman will be greedy, and vatmoss is a clusterfuck in its own right, but vat as a concept is actually extremely business-friendly. (I say that as someone who hates it for the regressive flat-tax on the poor that it actually is; I'd be happy to lose it tomorrow in exchange for higher corporation tax, but that won't make you any happier...)
the actual numbers above are examples, but the scenario matches mine pretty much perfectly, so I'm not sure why you would say that I'm misrepresenting anything
these are digital services, not cars or cans of soup
There should be a single source of truth for the rates data, and there should be an api instead of having to rely on a third party for that information.