Are they mandated to pay cash? I've heard from a few threads on reddit that many will pay in vouchers, a dozen $100 vouchers that can't be used together.
But if it was voluntary, the monetary option is not mandated. So when they ask if anyone wants to volunteer for a voucher, accepting that offer is volunteering, and writing yourself out of the cash option. (The airline can still offer it, but they no longer have to offer it).
How can this be ethical? The customer is doing a favor by giving up their seat, shouldn't they at least tell them what options are available?
If I were an airline employee, I'd need to draw out a flowchart to remember all this.